"The main peculiarity which distinguishes man from other animals is the means of his support-the power which he possesses of very greatly increasing these means"
About this Quote
Malthus frames humanity’s “peculiarity” with the cool, quasi-biological gaze of an economist watching a species misread its own talent. The line sounds like praise - man can “very greatly” increase the means of support - but the compliment is booby-trapped. It’s not just that humans can grow more food, build tools, or organize labor; it’s that this power tempts us into thinking we’ve outrun constraint itself. Malthus chooses “support” instead of “wealth” or “progress,” a narrowing that drags grand Enlightenment talk down to calories, shelter, and the brute arithmetic of survival.
The subtext is a warning about feedback loops. Our capacity to expand resources isn’t an escape hatch; it’s an accelerant. Increased support enables population growth, which then consumes the gains and pushes a society back toward scarcity. That’s the Malthusian sting: human ingenuity is real, but it operates inside a system where demand multiplies faster than supply can comfortably keep up. The quote’s clinical tone is part of the rhetoric. By placing “man” alongside “other animals,” he strips away moral exceptionalism and invites the reader to see economic life as ecology.
Context matters: writing at the turn of the 19th century, amid rapid population increases and early industrial change, Malthus was intervening against rosy utopian forecasts (like Godwin and Condorcet) that reason and reform would deliver indefinite improvement. His sentence is engineered to puncture that optimism while sounding like common sense, a polite understatement masking a fairly radical claim: the engine of human progress also manufactures the conditions for human stress.
The subtext is a warning about feedback loops. Our capacity to expand resources isn’t an escape hatch; it’s an accelerant. Increased support enables population growth, which then consumes the gains and pushes a society back toward scarcity. That’s the Malthusian sting: human ingenuity is real, but it operates inside a system where demand multiplies faster than supply can comfortably keep up. The quote’s clinical tone is part of the rhetoric. By placing “man” alongside “other animals,” he strips away moral exceptionalism and invites the reader to see economic life as ecology.
Context matters: writing at the turn of the 19th century, amid rapid population increases and early industrial change, Malthus was intervening against rosy utopian forecasts (like Godwin and Condorcet) that reason and reform would deliver indefinite improvement. His sentence is engineered to puncture that optimism while sounding like common sense, a polite understatement masking a fairly radical claim: the engine of human progress also manufactures the conditions for human stress.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Thomas
Add to List









