"The men whose manhood you have broken will loathe you, and will always be brooding and scheming to strike a fresh blow"
About this Quote
Power doesn’t just win fights; it manufactures enemies. Larkin’s line is a warning dressed as a prediction, aimed at employers, police, and politicians who thought “order” could be restored by humiliating workers into submission. The phrase “manhood you have broken” is doing double duty: it names real material crushing (blacklists, beatings, hunger) while also invoking the era’s gendered code of dignity. In early 20th-century labor politics, “manhood” meant the right to stand upright in public life, to provide, to refuse being treated as disposable. Break that, and you don’t get gratitude or compliance. You get a long memory.
The verb choice is surgical. “Loathe” isn’t disagreement; it’s moral revulsion, a response to degradation. “Brooding and scheming” rejects the comforting fantasy that resentment dissipates with time. Larkin frames injured pride as organized potential energy, not a passing mood. The “fresh blow” is especially pointed: it implies the first blow has already been struck by authority, and any retaliation will be painted as sudden or criminal unless you remember who started the violence.
Context matters because Larkin was speaking from Ireland’s labor cauldron: lockouts, strikebreaking, state force, and the wider nationalist ferment. His intent isn’t to romanticize vengeance but to argue that repression is strategically stupid. Crush people publicly and you radicalize them privately. He’s telling power brokers: you can break bodies and livelihoods, but the humiliation you bank today comes due later, with interest.
The verb choice is surgical. “Loathe” isn’t disagreement; it’s moral revulsion, a response to degradation. “Brooding and scheming” rejects the comforting fantasy that resentment dissipates with time. Larkin frames injured pride as organized potential energy, not a passing mood. The “fresh blow” is especially pointed: it implies the first blow has already been struck by authority, and any retaliation will be painted as sudden or criminal unless you remember who started the violence.
Context matters because Larkin was speaking from Ireland’s labor cauldron: lockouts, strikebreaking, state force, and the wider nationalist ferment. His intent isn’t to romanticize vengeance but to argue that repression is strategically stupid. Crush people publicly and you radicalize them privately. He’s telling power brokers: you can break bodies and livelihoods, but the humiliation you bank today comes due later, with interest.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|
More Quotes by James
Add to List










