"The misery in war-torn Afghanistan is reminiscent of images from the Thirty Years' War"
About this Quote
Habermas reaches for the Thirty Years' War because it’s a European catastrophe that still functions as a moral origin story: a continent supposedly learned, through burned villages and sectarian fanaticism, that politics can’t be left to absolutes. By yoking Afghanistan to that memory, he’s not just saying “things look bad.” He’s quietly indicting the complacent idea that modernity immunizes anyone from pre-modern ruin. If early modern Europe could collapse into decades of roaming armies, famine, and state failure, then the spectacle of Afghanistan as an endless emergency isn’t an exotic exception; it’s a recognizable product of shattered institutions and weaponized belief.
The analogy also does strategic work inside Habermas’s lifelong project: defending a rules-based, postnational order against both nationalist romanticism and realpolitik cynicism. The Thirty Years' War is what happens when sovereignty is a license to kill and diplomacy is subordinate to theological certainty. Afghanistan, in this frame, becomes a warning about the vacuum created when foreign intervention, proxy politics, and local power struggles grind down any shared public sphere. It’s less an ethnographic comparison than a mirror held up to the West’s self-image.
Subtext: Europe’s “civilizing” narratives are reversible, and the moral distance between “there” and “here” is a comforting fiction. The sting is that Habermas uses European history to make Afghanistan legible to Europeans, implying that empathy in the metropole still too often requires a familiar reference point.
The analogy also does strategic work inside Habermas’s lifelong project: defending a rules-based, postnational order against both nationalist romanticism and realpolitik cynicism. The Thirty Years' War is what happens when sovereignty is a license to kill and diplomacy is subordinate to theological certainty. Afghanistan, in this frame, becomes a warning about the vacuum created when foreign intervention, proxy politics, and local power struggles grind down any shared public sphere. It’s less an ethnographic comparison than a mirror held up to the West’s self-image.
Subtext: Europe’s “civilizing” narratives are reversible, and the moral distance between “there” and “here” is a comforting fiction. The sting is that Habermas uses European history to make Afghanistan legible to Europeans, implying that empathy in the metropole still too often requires a familiar reference point.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Jurgen
Add to List





