"The mob is a sort of bear; while your ring is through its nose, it will even dance under your cudgel; but should the ring slip, and you lose your hold, the brute will turn and rend you"
About this Quote
Porter’s image is almost offensively physical: politics as animal handling, persuasion as a pierced nose, authority as a cudgel. It’s not just a metaphor for “crowds are fickle.” It’s a warning about the cheap thrill of control. The mob “will even dance” - a grotesque little entertainment - as long as leaders can keep the pain precise and the leash tight. That verb choice matters: “dance” implies choreography, a performance of consent staged by whoever holds the ring.
The subtext is that crowd management is never stable, and never morally neutral. The ring isn’t legitimacy; it’s leverage. The cudgel isn’t law; it’s coercion. Porter makes the mechanics of power feel intimate and ugly, as if demagogues and would-be reformers alike are doing the same work: training a mass of people through fear, spectacle, and humiliation. The moment you start relying on those tools, you’re trapped by them. Lose your grip and the “brute will turn and rend you” - not because the crowd is inherently monstrous, but because you taught it a relationship built on force, not trust.
Contextually, Porter is writing in the long shadow of the French Revolution and the age of popular agitation in Britain, when “the people” could be invoked as moral authority or dismissed as a threat. Her line threads that needle with cynicism and anxiety: mass politics is real power, but it’s volatile, and those who instrumentalize it mistake domination for loyalty.
The subtext is that crowd management is never stable, and never morally neutral. The ring isn’t legitimacy; it’s leverage. The cudgel isn’t law; it’s coercion. Porter makes the mechanics of power feel intimate and ugly, as if demagogues and would-be reformers alike are doing the same work: training a mass of people through fear, spectacle, and humiliation. The moment you start relying on those tools, you’re trapped by them. Lose your grip and the “brute will turn and rend you” - not because the crowd is inherently monstrous, but because you taught it a relationship built on force, not trust.
Contextually, Porter is writing in the long shadow of the French Revolution and the age of popular agitation in Britain, when “the people” could be invoked as moral authority or dismissed as a threat. Her line threads that needle with cynicism and anxiety: mass politics is real power, but it’s volatile, and those who instrumentalize it mistake domination for loyalty.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|
More Quotes by Jane
Add to List
