"The mongers brought them together upon a mutual surrender of their principles"
About this Quote
A politician calling other politicians "mongers" is never just name-calling; it is an accusation that the whole system has been reduced to peddling. Robert Toombs, the Georgia fire-eater who helped steer the South toward secession, uses the marketplace metaphor to sneer at coalition-building as commerce: deals brokered by hustlers, not deliberations among statesmen. "Brought them together" sounds almost wholesome until the hinge phrase lands: "upon a mutual surrender of their principles". Unity, in this framing, is not a civic achievement but a telltale symptom of rot.
The line’s intent is surgical. Toombs isn’t arguing policy; he’s delegitimizing the process by implying that any compromise is a kind of moral liquidation. The choice of "mutual" matters: nobody gets to claim the high ground. Each side is implicated, each party bought, each conscience discounted. It’s a rhetorical move designed to corral the audience into a hard binary - purity or corruption - and to make ideological rigidity feel like integrity rather than obstinacy.
Contextually, Toombs operated in the fevered antebellum world where national bargains over slavery, tariffs, and territorial expansion were constantly being stitched together, then denounced as betrayals. His subtext is a warning and a provocation: if the center can be assembled only by trading away convictions, then the center deserves to collapse. The sentence works because it weaponizes cynicism while posing as virtue, turning "principles" into both moral currency and moral alibi.
The line’s intent is surgical. Toombs isn’t arguing policy; he’s delegitimizing the process by implying that any compromise is a kind of moral liquidation. The choice of "mutual" matters: nobody gets to claim the high ground. Each side is implicated, each party bought, each conscience discounted. It’s a rhetorical move designed to corral the audience into a hard binary - purity or corruption - and to make ideological rigidity feel like integrity rather than obstinacy.
Contextually, Toombs operated in the fevered antebellum world where national bargains over slavery, tariffs, and territorial expansion were constantly being stitched together, then denounced as betrayals. His subtext is a warning and a provocation: if the center can be assembled only by trading away convictions, then the center deserves to collapse. The sentence works because it weaponizes cynicism while posing as virtue, turning "principles" into both moral currency and moral alibi.
Quote Details
| Topic | Honesty & Integrity |
|---|
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List





