"The more ignorant, reckless and thoughtless a doctor is, the higher his reputation soars even amongst powerful princes"
About this Quote
Erasmus doesn’t lob this as a stray insult at bad doctors; he uses medicine as a scalpel for a broader civic pathology: power’s preference for confidence over competence. The line is built on a deliberately inverted logic - the worse the physician, the better the career - and that reversal is the whole trick. It’s funny in the sour way Erasmus specializes in, because it’s plausible. Reputation, he implies, isn’t a merit badge handed out by reasoned observers; it’s a social hallucination produced by status, fear, and flattery.
The target is “powerful princes,” a phrase that matters. Erasmus is writing in a world where courts function as rumor engines and where expertise is as much performance as knowledge. A reckless doctor can appear decisive, unburdened by doubt, happily prescribing dramatic interventions that read as action. A cautious, thoughtful physician - the kind likely to admit uncertainty - risks looking weak. Princes, trained to treat hesitation as disloyalty, reward the swagger.
There’s also a theological and humanist undertow. Erasmus, the great critic of clerical corruption and institutional vanity, is mapping the same dynamic onto a different profession: people in authority don’t just tolerate charlatans; they often select for them, because charlatans are easier to manage. The subtext is less “medicine is broken” than “judgment at the top is broken,” and once that’s true, ignorance isn’t a barrier to prestige - it’s a credential.
The target is “powerful princes,” a phrase that matters. Erasmus is writing in a world where courts function as rumor engines and where expertise is as much performance as knowledge. A reckless doctor can appear decisive, unburdened by doubt, happily prescribing dramatic interventions that read as action. A cautious, thoughtful physician - the kind likely to admit uncertainty - risks looking weak. Princes, trained to treat hesitation as disloyalty, reward the swagger.
There’s also a theological and humanist undertow. Erasmus, the great critic of clerical corruption and institutional vanity, is mapping the same dynamic onto a different profession: people in authority don’t just tolerate charlatans; they often select for them, because charlatans are easier to manage. The subtext is less “medicine is broken” than “judgment at the top is broken,” and once that’s true, ignorance isn’t a barrier to prestige - it’s a credential.
Quote Details
| Topic | Doctor |
|---|
More Quotes by Desiderius
Add to List









