"The most radical revolutionary will become a conservative the day after the revolution"
About this Quote
The radical who tears down an old order wakes the next morning to a new burden: guarding what has been created from the same forces of disruption that once animated the revolt. Arendt points to a structural transformation in political time. Revolution is a moment of beginning, a leap into the new, but politics the day after is about making beginnings durable. Laws must be written, institutions built, authority legitimated, and the fragile space of shared freedom protected. Once there is something to lose, even a revolutionary acquires a conserving impulse. Conservatism here is not an ideology of the right; it is the posture of preservation that attends any founding.
Arendt’s reflections in On Revolution turn on this pivot from liberation to freedom. Toppling oppression is only the first act; the harder task is creating lasting institutions that secure a public realm where citizens can act and speak together. The American founders, she argued, succeeded because they channeled revolutionary energy into constitutional craftsmanship and a federated structure that could stabilize novelty. The French, preoccupied with the social question, let the energy of the streets overwhelm the work of founding, and terror followed. In both cases, however, once a constitution or a revolutionary government exists, those who made it become its guardians, wary of further upheaval that could dissolve the order they just risked everything to establish.
Examples across modern history confirm the pattern. Bolsheviks who promised permanent revolution rapidly consolidated a state apparatus and suppressed dissent to defend the revolution’s gains. Even fiery Jacobins became custodians of virtue and order. The point is not hypocrisy but a political law: beginnings demand conservation. Arendt’s aphorism is both insight and caution. It warns that the spirit of revolution cannot be permanent without devouring freedom, and it reminds founders that the legitimacy of what they conserve must remain anchored in the participatory, plural, and open-ended practice that made the beginning meaningful in the first place.
Arendt’s reflections in On Revolution turn on this pivot from liberation to freedom. Toppling oppression is only the first act; the harder task is creating lasting institutions that secure a public realm where citizens can act and speak together. The American founders, she argued, succeeded because they channeled revolutionary energy into constitutional craftsmanship and a federated structure that could stabilize novelty. The French, preoccupied with the social question, let the energy of the streets overwhelm the work of founding, and terror followed. In both cases, however, once a constitution or a revolutionary government exists, those who made it become its guardians, wary of further upheaval that could dissolve the order they just risked everything to establish.
Examples across modern history confirm the pattern. Bolsheviks who promised permanent revolution rapidly consolidated a state apparatus and suppressed dissent to defend the revolution’s gains. Even fiery Jacobins became custodians of virtue and order. The point is not hypocrisy but a political law: beginnings demand conservation. Arendt’s aphorism is both insight and caution. It warns that the spirit of revolution cannot be permanent without devouring freedom, and it reminds founders that the legitimacy of what they conserve must remain anchored in the participatory, plural, and open-ended practice that made the beginning meaningful in the first place.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Hannah
Add to List
