"The natural progress of things is for liberty to yield and government to gain ground"
About this Quote
Jefferson’s line lands like a warning dressed as a law of physics: left alone, power doesn’t just expand - it settles, spreads, and hardens. The phrasing is the trick. By calling it “natural progress,” he strips away the comforting story that freedom is the default setting and tyranny is an aberration. Government “gain[ing] ground” sounds almost botanical, like weeds taking an untended garden. Liberty, meanwhile, doesn’t get “taken”; it “yields,” a verb that implies quiet surrender, small concessions, gradual accommodation. The menace here is incrementalism.
The specific intent is political discipline. Jefferson is not urging anarchy; he’s arguing that the burden of proof belongs to the state, and that citizens have to treat skepticism as civic hygiene. The subtext is a diagnosis of human incentives: institutions exist to perpetuate themselves, officials rationalize expansion as necessity, and emergencies - real or manufactured - become the pretext for permanent authority. “Liberty” isn’t defeated in a dramatic coup; it gets traded away for administrative convenience.
Context matters because Jefferson is a founder who helped build the very machinery he’s distrusting. That tension gives the sentence its bite. Coming from a president, it reads less like romantic anti-state rhetoric and more like an insider’s memo: even a republic designed to limit power will drift toward centralization unless actively resisted. It’s a reminder that freedom is not self-executing; it requires maintenance, and maintenance is work people love to postpone until it’s too late.
The specific intent is political discipline. Jefferson is not urging anarchy; he’s arguing that the burden of proof belongs to the state, and that citizens have to treat skepticism as civic hygiene. The subtext is a diagnosis of human incentives: institutions exist to perpetuate themselves, officials rationalize expansion as necessity, and emergencies - real or manufactured - become the pretext for permanent authority. “Liberty” isn’t defeated in a dramatic coup; it gets traded away for administrative convenience.
Context matters because Jefferson is a founder who helped build the very machinery he’s distrusting. That tension gives the sentence its bite. Coming from a president, it reads less like romantic anti-state rhetoric and more like an insider’s memo: even a republic designed to limit power will drift toward centralization unless actively resisted. It’s a reminder that freedom is not self-executing; it requires maintenance, and maintenance is work people love to postpone until it’s too late.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Thomas
Add to List









