"The necessity of every one paying in his own labor for what he consumes, affords the only legitimate and effectual check to excessive luxury, which has so often ruined individuals, states and empires; and which has now brought almost universal bankruptcy upon us"
About this Quote
Warren’s sentence reads like an inventor’s blueprint for morality: take away the credit system, bolt consumption to personal labor, and the machine of “excessive luxury” stops overheating. The intent isn’t just to scold rich people for decadence. It’s to propose a practical, enforceable brake on an economy he sees as structurally tempted to overspend. “Legitimate and effectual check” is doing heavy work here: Warren wants restraint that isn’t imposed by sermons, laws, or elites, but built into the terms of exchange themselves.
The subtext is a critique of an emerging capitalism where distance from labor enables fantasy. Luxury becomes “excessive” when payment is abstracted - through speculation, debt, and the social permission to consume without producing. By insisting everyone “pay in his own labor,” Warren is attacking both inherited privilege and financial trickery: the ability to live off rents, interest, or paper promises. He’s also selling a radical kind of fairness that doubles as social engineering; if every purchase carries the memory of your own hours, desire is forced to negotiate with fatigue.
Context matters: Warren is writing in a 19th-century America roiled by boom-and-bust cycles and the moral panic around debt, banks, and “paper money.” His reference to “almost universal bankruptcy” isn’t apocalyptic flourish; it’s a snapshot of a society repeatedly shocked by financial crises. The line works because it scales from the personal to the imperial without changing its logic: when consumption floats free of labor, collapse isn’t an accident, it’s the business model.
The subtext is a critique of an emerging capitalism where distance from labor enables fantasy. Luxury becomes “excessive” when payment is abstracted - through speculation, debt, and the social permission to consume without producing. By insisting everyone “pay in his own labor,” Warren is attacking both inherited privilege and financial trickery: the ability to live off rents, interest, or paper promises. He’s also selling a radical kind of fairness that doubles as social engineering; if every purchase carries the memory of your own hours, desire is forced to negotiate with fatigue.
Context matters: Warren is writing in a 19th-century America roiled by boom-and-bust cycles and the moral panic around debt, banks, and “paper money.” His reference to “almost universal bankruptcy” isn’t apocalyptic flourish; it’s a snapshot of a society repeatedly shocked by financial crises. The line works because it scales from the personal to the imperial without changing its logic: when consumption floats free of labor, collapse isn’t an accident, it’s the business model.
Quote Details
| Topic | Money |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Josiah
Add to List
