"The New England conscience doesn't keep you from doing what you shouldn't - it just keeps you from enjoying it"
About this Quote
A whole moral system, punctured with one pin: the New England conscience isn’t a guardrail, it’s a wet blanket. Singer’s line works because it refuses the flattering fantasy that righteousness reliably produces good behavior. Instead, it proposes something more psychologically accurate and more culturally irritating: people will do what they want, and the real power of a strict moral culture is its ability to poison pleasure after the fact.
The target is recognizable. “New England” stands in for a particular Anglo-Protestant inheritance: self-scrutiny, restraint, the internal auditor who never clocks out. Singer doesn’t paint it as heroic discipline so much as an emotional tax. You can break the rule, but you can’t cash in the thrill. That’s the joke, and it lands because it’s not only about sin; it’s about the modern habit of converting desire into a performance review.
Singer’s subtext has an outsider’s bite. As a Jewish novelist steeped in Old World communities and their own intricate moral economies, he’s alert to how conscience can function less as ethical clarity than as social technology: a mechanism for control that migrates into the psyche. The “conscience” here isn’t divine guidance; it’s cultural conditioning, the voice of a community embedded in the individual, still policing them even in private.
It’s also quietly compassionate. If guilt can’t stop the act, what it mostly produces is misery. Singer sketches a bleak bargain: you get the transgression, but you don’t get the relief. The punishment is pre-installed, running in the background.
The target is recognizable. “New England” stands in for a particular Anglo-Protestant inheritance: self-scrutiny, restraint, the internal auditor who never clocks out. Singer doesn’t paint it as heroic discipline so much as an emotional tax. You can break the rule, but you can’t cash in the thrill. That’s the joke, and it lands because it’s not only about sin; it’s about the modern habit of converting desire into a performance review.
Singer’s subtext has an outsider’s bite. As a Jewish novelist steeped in Old World communities and their own intricate moral economies, he’s alert to how conscience can function less as ethical clarity than as social technology: a mechanism for control that migrates into the psyche. The “conscience” here isn’t divine guidance; it’s cultural conditioning, the voice of a community embedded in the individual, still policing them even in private.
It’s also quietly compassionate. If guilt can’t stop the act, what it mostly produces is misery. Singer sketches a bleak bargain: you get the transgression, but you don’t get the relief. The punishment is pre-installed, running in the background.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Isaac
Add to List






