"The only model to follow is pure Islam"
About this Quote
“Pure Islam” is doing the heavy lifting here: it’s not a devotional phrase so much as a political weapon. Abu Bakar Bashir’s line compresses an entire program into a clean, uncompromising slogan, built to sound less like an opinion than an instruction manual. The word “only” shuts down pluralism in one stroke. “Model” reframes faith as governance and social architecture, not just personal belief. And “pure” smuggles in a moral hierarchy: if there’s a pure Islam, then most Muslims are, by implication, practicing something diluted, corrupted, or counterfeit.
That subtext matters because it solves a common problem for hardline movements: how to delegitimize existing institutions without sounding merely partisan. Bashir doesn’t need to name elections, constitutions, local traditions, or rival clerics; the phrase “pure Islam” already casts them as compromise. It’s a rhetorical cleansing agent, offering certainty to followers who feel humiliated by modernity, state corruption, or Western influence, while also creating permission structures for coercion: if purity is the goal, then policing belief and behavior becomes a “restoration,” not repression.
Context sharpens the intent. Bashir is associated with Indonesia’s militant Islamist milieu and the ideological ecosystem around Jemaah Islamiyah, in a country famous for Muslim diversity and pragmatic syncretism. The quote is tailored to that landscape: it draws a bright line against Indonesia’s pluralist national identity and its messy, negotiated Islam. It’s recruitment language, but also a claim to exclusive legitimacy. The appeal is its simplicity; the danger is its narrowing of who counts.
That subtext matters because it solves a common problem for hardline movements: how to delegitimize existing institutions without sounding merely partisan. Bashir doesn’t need to name elections, constitutions, local traditions, or rival clerics; the phrase “pure Islam” already casts them as compromise. It’s a rhetorical cleansing agent, offering certainty to followers who feel humiliated by modernity, state corruption, or Western influence, while also creating permission structures for coercion: if purity is the goal, then policing belief and behavior becomes a “restoration,” not repression.
Context sharpens the intent. Bashir is associated with Indonesia’s militant Islamist milieu and the ideological ecosystem around Jemaah Islamiyah, in a country famous for Muslim diversity and pragmatic syncretism. The quote is tailored to that landscape: it draws a bright line against Indonesia’s pluralist national identity and its messy, negotiated Islam. It’s recruitment language, but also a claim to exclusive legitimacy. The appeal is its simplicity; the danger is its narrowing of who counts.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|
More Quotes by Abu
Add to List


