"The ordinary man casts a shadow in a way we do not quite understand. The man of genius casts light"
About this Quote
Steiner’s line flatters genius while quietly indicting the rest of us, and it does so with a critic’s favorite weapon: metaphor that pretends to be neutral description. “The ordinary man casts a shadow” is not just an image of obscurity; it suggests unintended consequence. A shadow is produced simply by standing somewhere, blocking light that existed before you arrived. Ordinary life, in Steiner’s formulation, is reactive and occlusive: we take up space, we interrupt illumination, we leave a vague darkness whose shape we “do not quite understand.” That last clause is the barb. It’s not only that the ordinary person lacks insight; it’s that the ordinary person doesn’t even grasp how their presence diminishes what could be seen.
Then comes the clean, priestly reversal: “The man of genius casts light.” Genius doesn’t merely avoid blocking illumination; it generates it. The phrasing borrows the moral grammar of revelation. Light implies clarity, moral orientation, even salvation - a way of seeing that reorganizes a room, a culture, a century.
Context matters: Steiner spent a lifetime policing the boundary between high culture and mass culture, defending the strenuous pleasures of serious art while mourning a modernity he saw as flattening depth. This sentence performs that worldview in miniature. It’s an argument for hierarchy disguised as a phenomenological observation: some people are bulbs; most are silhouettes.
The subtext is both elegiac and elitist. Steiner isn’t just praising exceptional minds; he’s defending the critic’s vocation as a kind of electrician for civilization - tracing where light originates, and naming the shadows we’ve learned to live with.
Then comes the clean, priestly reversal: “The man of genius casts light.” Genius doesn’t merely avoid blocking illumination; it generates it. The phrasing borrows the moral grammar of revelation. Light implies clarity, moral orientation, even salvation - a way of seeing that reorganizes a room, a culture, a century.
Context matters: Steiner spent a lifetime policing the boundary between high culture and mass culture, defending the strenuous pleasures of serious art while mourning a modernity he saw as flattening depth. This sentence performs that worldview in miniature. It’s an argument for hierarchy disguised as a phenomenological observation: some people are bulbs; most are silhouettes.
The subtext is both elegiac and elitist. Steiner isn’t just praising exceptional minds; he’s defending the critic’s vocation as a kind of electrician for civilization - tracing where light originates, and naming the shadows we’ve learned to live with.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by George
Add to List
