"The people who do not get jobs are often the most vulnerable in our society, and joblessness is a terrible plight for anyone who suffers from it"
About this Quote
Bishop’s line is doing two jobs at once: it humanizes unemployment while quietly rewriting the political math around it. By naming the jobless as “often the most vulnerable,” he rejects the familiar insinuation that unemployment is primarily a personal failing. The phrasing is careful, almost legalistic. “Often” leaves room for exceptions, but the thrust is unmistakable: when the labor market shuts people out, it tends to shut out those with the least cushioning - the disabled, the under-educated, the discriminated-against, the people one setback away from free fall.
Then comes the pivot from sociology to moral pressure: “joblessness is a terrible plight for anyone.” That broadened “anyone” matters. It’s a politician’s way of expanding empathy beyond the stereotyped “deserving poor” and making unemployment a shared civic risk, not a niche problem. The subtext is coalition-building: if everyone can imagine themselves on the wrong side of a layoff, then policies that treat unemployment as a collective emergency become easier to sell.
Contextually, this sounds like an argument aimed at budget hawks and tough-love rhetoric in debates over welfare, training programs, or stimulus spending. Bishop isn’t offering a statistic; he’s offering a frame. “Plight” is an old, dignifying word, one that recasts the unemployed as people in a condition imposed on them, not people who chose it. The intent is to make compassion politically defensible - and austerity harder to justify.
Then comes the pivot from sociology to moral pressure: “joblessness is a terrible plight for anyone.” That broadened “anyone” matters. It’s a politician’s way of expanding empathy beyond the stereotyped “deserving poor” and making unemployment a shared civic risk, not a niche problem. The subtext is coalition-building: if everyone can imagine themselves on the wrong side of a layoff, then policies that treat unemployment as a collective emergency become easier to sell.
Contextually, this sounds like an argument aimed at budget hawks and tough-love rhetoric in debates over welfare, training programs, or stimulus spending. Bishop isn’t offering a statistic; he’s offering a frame. “Plight” is an old, dignifying word, one that recasts the unemployed as people in a condition imposed on them, not people who chose it. The intent is to make compassion politically defensible - and austerity harder to justify.
Quote Details
| Topic | Work |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Tim
Add to List




