"The perceptive act is a reaction of the mind upon the object of which it is the perception"
About this Quote
Perception, in Samuel Alexander's hands, isn’t a camera click. It’s closer to a collision. The line insists that seeing is never passive reception but an active event: mind presses back on what it meets. That choice of phrasing - "reaction of the mind upon the object" - carries a quiet provocation. It denies the comforting idea that the world simply imprints itself on us, untouched. Instead, it makes perception a kind of participation, even a mild intervention, where the object-as-perceived is inseparable from the mind’s stance, habits, and readiness.
The subtext is a rebuke to both naive realism ("things are exactly as they appear") and to the more solipsistic temptation ("everything is just in your head"). Alexander threads a third path: the object is real, but perception is an emergent relationship, a transaction. What you get is not the object alone, and not the mind alone, but a structured encounter shaped by attention, memory, and the mind’s selective pressures.
Context matters: Alexander is writing in an early 20th-century philosophical landscape where British idealism is losing its monopoly, science is remaking what counts as knowledge, and thinkers are searching for frameworks that respect both the independence of the world and the activity of consciousness. His broader project (a metaphysics of "emergence") makes the sentence click: perception is a higher-level phenomenon arising from mind-in-world contact. The line works because it reframes a familiar act - looking - as a dynamic, consequential exchange, making objectivity something achieved, not given.
The subtext is a rebuke to both naive realism ("things are exactly as they appear") and to the more solipsistic temptation ("everything is just in your head"). Alexander threads a third path: the object is real, but perception is an emergent relationship, a transaction. What you get is not the object alone, and not the mind alone, but a structured encounter shaped by attention, memory, and the mind’s selective pressures.
Context matters: Alexander is writing in an early 20th-century philosophical landscape where British idealism is losing its monopoly, science is remaking what counts as knowledge, and thinkers are searching for frameworks that respect both the independence of the world and the activity of consciousness. His broader project (a metaphysics of "emergence") makes the sentence click: perception is a higher-level phenomenon arising from mind-in-world contact. The line works because it reframes a familiar act - looking - as a dynamic, consequential exchange, making objectivity something achieved, not given.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Samuel
Add to List





