"The plants which stand next to dwarf trees in importance with the Chinese are certainly chrysanthemums, which they manage extremely well, perhaps better than they do any other plant"
About this Quote
Fortune’s praise lands with the tidy confidence of a Victorian field note, but its real work is cultural bookkeeping: ranking what a civilization values, then converting that value into a measurable “importance” legible to Western eyes. By putting chrysanthemums just behind dwarf trees, he turns living things into a hierarchy of national taste, as if Chinese horticulture were an exhibit with labeled tiers. The tone is admiring, yet it carries the quiet authority of the outsider who assumes he can weigh another culture’s priorities from the greenhouse outward.
Context matters. Fortune wasn’t a neutral garden tourist; he was a plant hunter operating in the long 19th century, when botany braided itself to commerce and empire. His observations fed a European appetite for collectible exotica and, more pointedly, systems of extraction and acclimatization: find what a place does “better,” document it, transport it, sell it. “They manage extremely well” is compliment as credential, the kind that justifies why these plants deserve attention, study, and ultimately relocation into Western markets and prestige gardens.
The subtext is also about control. To “manage” a plant implies mastery, technique, refinement - all flattering - but it also frames Chinese horticulture as a set of replicable tricks rather than a tradition with its own meanings. Chrysanthemums in China aren’t merely ornamental; they carry seasonal, poetic, and scholarly associations. Fortune’s line trims that symbolic density down to performance. The sentence works because it’s so seemingly benign: admiration that doubles as inventory, wonder that still keeps the observer in charge of the ledger.
Context matters. Fortune wasn’t a neutral garden tourist; he was a plant hunter operating in the long 19th century, when botany braided itself to commerce and empire. His observations fed a European appetite for collectible exotica and, more pointedly, systems of extraction and acclimatization: find what a place does “better,” document it, transport it, sell it. “They manage extremely well” is compliment as credential, the kind that justifies why these plants deserve attention, study, and ultimately relocation into Western markets and prestige gardens.
The subtext is also about control. To “manage” a plant implies mastery, technique, refinement - all flattering - but it also frames Chinese horticulture as a set of replicable tricks rather than a tradition with its own meanings. Chrysanthemums in China aren’t merely ornamental; they carry seasonal, poetic, and scholarly associations. Fortune’s line trims that symbolic density down to performance. The sentence works because it’s so seemingly benign: admiration that doubles as inventory, wonder that still keeps the observer in charge of the ledger.
Quote Details
| Topic | Nature |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List
