"The poets have been mysteriously silent on the subject of cheese"
About this Quote
Chesterton lands this like a dinner-table epigram: a ridiculous observation that quietly indicts our idea of what counts as “serious” art. The joke is the mismatch between poetry’s lofty reputation and cheese’s stubborn, pungent materiality. Poets can rhapsodize about wine, roses, nightingales, even bread in its biblical glow, but cheese sits there as the unglamorous proof that the body has demands. Chesterton’s “mysteriously silent” is doing extra work: it implies not just omission, but a kind of collective conspiracy, as if bards everywhere agreed to avert their eyes from the dairy case.
The intent isn’t culinary criticism; it’s a jab at aesthetic snobbery and a defense of the ordinary. Chesterton often argued that modern sophistication mistakes simple pleasures for simple-mindedness. Cheese, in this line, becomes shorthand for the everyday joys that intellectual culture refuses to dignify. It’s also a sly comment on how artistic canons get built: not by what humans actually love, but by what feels “proper” to praise. If poetry is supposed to enlarge life, why does it keep skipping over a food that’s intimate, communal, and frankly ecstatic?
Context matters. Chesterton wrote in an era when “high” culture and “low” culture were hardening into separate social signals. By choosing cheese - homely, regional, peasant-coded - he needles the class instincts inside taste. The punchline isn’t that poets should write odes to cheddar. It’s that they should admit the world is wider than their approved metaphors, and that wonder doesn’t only happen in moonlight; it happens on a plate.
The intent isn’t culinary criticism; it’s a jab at aesthetic snobbery and a defense of the ordinary. Chesterton often argued that modern sophistication mistakes simple pleasures for simple-mindedness. Cheese, in this line, becomes shorthand for the everyday joys that intellectual culture refuses to dignify. It’s also a sly comment on how artistic canons get built: not by what humans actually love, but by what feels “proper” to praise. If poetry is supposed to enlarge life, why does it keep skipping over a food that’s intimate, communal, and frankly ecstatic?
Context matters. Chesterton wrote in an era when “high” culture and “low” culture were hardening into separate social signals. By choosing cheese - homely, regional, peasant-coded - he needles the class instincts inside taste. The punchline isn’t that poets should write odes to cheddar. It’s that they should admit the world is wider than their approved metaphors, and that wonder doesn’t only happen in moonlight; it happens on a plate.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Gilbert
Add to List





