"The priest is an immense being because he makes the crowd believe astonishing things"
About this Quote
Baudelaire’s line lands like a compliment that curdles on contact. Calling the priest “immense” sounds reverent, until you notice what’s doing the enlarging: not holiness, not virtue, but the ability to manufacture belief at scale. Immensity here isn’t moral greatness; it’s social mass. The priest becomes monumental because a crowd grants him that size, and because he knows how to work the crowd’s hunger for meaning, fear, and spectacle.
Baudelaire is writing out of 19th-century France, where Catholic authority was being renegotiated amid modernization, political upheaval, and a growing bourgeois public. The “astonishing things” are not just miracles in the doctrinal sense; they’re the audacity of any narrative that asks people to suspend ordinary skepticism. He’s fascinated by the mechanics: how language, ritual, architecture, and performance turn abstractions into lived reality. The priest is less a spiritual guide than a virtuoso of collective imagination.
Subtext: the crowd is complicit. Baudelaire doesn’t frame belief as mere deception imposed from above; he suggests a transaction. The priest offers astonishment, the crowd offers obedience and awe. That’s why the sentence stings: it demystifies charisma without denying its power. In Baudelaire’s world, modernity doesn’t eliminate enchantment; it relocates it into institutions and operators who can stage it convincingly. Replace “priest” with influencer, pundit, or founder and the anatomy remains: authority is the art of making improbable things feel necessary, shared, and true enough to organize a multitude.
Baudelaire is writing out of 19th-century France, where Catholic authority was being renegotiated amid modernization, political upheaval, and a growing bourgeois public. The “astonishing things” are not just miracles in the doctrinal sense; they’re the audacity of any narrative that asks people to suspend ordinary skepticism. He’s fascinated by the mechanics: how language, ritual, architecture, and performance turn abstractions into lived reality. The priest is less a spiritual guide than a virtuoso of collective imagination.
Subtext: the crowd is complicit. Baudelaire doesn’t frame belief as mere deception imposed from above; he suggests a transaction. The priest offers astonishment, the crowd offers obedience and awe. That’s why the sentence stings: it demystifies charisma without denying its power. In Baudelaire’s world, modernity doesn’t eliminate enchantment; it relocates it into institutions and operators who can stage it convincingly. Replace “priest” with influencer, pundit, or founder and the anatomy remains: authority is the art of making improbable things feel necessary, shared, and true enough to organize a multitude.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|
More Quotes by Charles
Add to List



