"The printed page conveys information and commitment, and requires active involvement. Television conveys emotion and experience, and it's very limited in what it can do logically. It's an existential experience - there and then gone"
About this Quote
Moyers draws a hard line between two kinds of attention: the slow, effortful work of reading and the fast, immersive pull of watching. He’s not just praising books out of nostalgia. He’s defending a civic muscle. “Commitment” is the tell: a printed page asks you to consent to its tempo, to wrestle with an argument, to hold competing claims in your head long enough for logic to matter. That “active involvement” isn’t a private virtue; it’s training for citizenship in a society that depends on people weighing evidence instead of simply absorbing vibes.
Television, in Moyers’ framing, is less a medium than a mood-delivery system. “Emotion and experience” aren’t insults on their own, but he’s warning that TV’s strengths tilt public life toward what can be felt instantly rather than what must be reasoned through. The word “limited” lands with a journalist’s frustration: you can show suffering, spectacle, charisma; you struggle to show causality, trade-offs, structural context without losing the audience to the next stimulus.
Calling it “existential” is slyly double-edged. Television excels at presence: the shared now, the sensation of being there. But that presence evaporates. “There and then gone” points to ephemerality as a political problem: if the primary record of reality is fleeting, hard to revisit, and shaped by producers’ choices, accountability thins out. The subtext is a quiet indictment of a culture that confuses being moved with being informed, and treats attention not as a responsibility but as a commodity to be harvested.
Television, in Moyers’ framing, is less a medium than a mood-delivery system. “Emotion and experience” aren’t insults on their own, but he’s warning that TV’s strengths tilt public life toward what can be felt instantly rather than what must be reasoned through. The word “limited” lands with a journalist’s frustration: you can show suffering, spectacle, charisma; you struggle to show causality, trade-offs, structural context without losing the audience to the next stimulus.
Calling it “existential” is slyly double-edged. Television excels at presence: the shared now, the sensation of being there. But that presence evaporates. “There and then gone” points to ephemerality as a political problem: if the primary record of reality is fleeting, hard to revisit, and shaped by producers’ choices, accountability thins out. The subtext is a quiet indictment of a culture that confuses being moved with being informed, and treats attention not as a responsibility but as a commodity to be harvested.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by Bill
Add to List
