"The problem is going to be finding the right words and implementing it in a way that is really dealing with people that are inciting and not preventing honest discussion of the underlying causes of this horrendous political situation the world is in now"
About this Quote
Clare Short points to the hardest part of democratic governance: drawing a bright line between confronting genuine incitement and protecting the space for candid inquiry. The challenge is not merely moral but linguistic and institutional. Find the wrong words and the effort turns into a blunt instrument that criminalizes dissent, chills criticism, and prevents the tough conversations about root causes. Find the right words and you enable targeted action against provocateurs while safeguarding the honest debate necessary to defuse crises.
Her emphasis on implementation acknowledges how laws, media norms, and policing practices can drift from intention. Vague labels like extremism or radicalization are easily stretched to include unpopular views, particularly when governments feel besieged. Short lived through the post-9/11 atmosphere and the lead-up to the Iraq War, when arguments about causes and consequences were often cast as disloyal or dangerous. That experience informs a plea for precision: define incitement narrowly, tethered to advocacy of violence, and avoid sweeping categories that muddle dissent with menace.
The phrase underlying causes carries the heart of her argument. Political violence, polarization, and social breakdown rarely appear from nowhere; they feed on humiliation, exclusion, corruption, occupation, and failed governance. If public conversation is narrowed by fear, stigma, or careless regulation, those drivers go unexamined and unaddressed. Meanwhile, demagogues thrive on grievance and oversimplification, and repression becomes their easiest foil.
Short also gestures to the power of language itself. Political rhetoric can either incite or inoculate. Words can escalate a sense of siege or widen a circle of empathy; they can flatten complex realities into slogans or open space for nuance. Getting the language right is not cosmetic; it is strategic. Without it, implementation falters, legitimacy erodes, and the cycle of provocation and crackdown intensifies. Her warning is clear: if we cannot distinguish between those who incite and those who inquire, we will neither solve the crisis nor learn why it persists.
Her emphasis on implementation acknowledges how laws, media norms, and policing practices can drift from intention. Vague labels like extremism or radicalization are easily stretched to include unpopular views, particularly when governments feel besieged. Short lived through the post-9/11 atmosphere and the lead-up to the Iraq War, when arguments about causes and consequences were often cast as disloyal or dangerous. That experience informs a plea for precision: define incitement narrowly, tethered to advocacy of violence, and avoid sweeping categories that muddle dissent with menace.
The phrase underlying causes carries the heart of her argument. Political violence, polarization, and social breakdown rarely appear from nowhere; they feed on humiliation, exclusion, corruption, occupation, and failed governance. If public conversation is narrowed by fear, stigma, or careless regulation, those drivers go unexamined and unaddressed. Meanwhile, demagogues thrive on grievance and oversimplification, and repression becomes their easiest foil.
Short also gestures to the power of language itself. Political rhetoric can either incite or inoculate. Words can escalate a sense of siege or widen a circle of empathy; they can flatten complex realities into slogans or open space for nuance. Getting the language right is not cosmetic; it is strategic. Without it, implementation falters, legitimacy erodes, and the cycle of provocation and crackdown intensifies. Her warning is clear: if we cannot distinguish between those who incite and those who inquire, we will neither solve the crisis nor learn why it persists.
Quote Details
| Topic | Peace |
|---|
More Quotes by Clare
Add to List
