"The problem with most people is that they think with their hopes or fears or wishes rather than their minds"
About this Quote
Duranty’s line lands like a tidy reprimand, but it’s really a diagnostic tool for mass politics: most people don’t reason toward conclusions, they recruit conclusions to soothe an emotion. “Hopes or fears or wishes” aren’t just distractions here; they’re engines. They provide the narrative fuel that turns messy facts into a story you can live with. The sting is in “rather than their minds,” a phrasing that pretends the mind is a neutral instrument when it’s often a lawyer for the heart. The sentence works because it flatters the reader’s self-image while indicting everyone else: you, presumably, are the rare exception who thinks.
The subtext is darker. As a journalist, Duranty is sketching the audience he had to persuade, manage, or outmaneuver. It’s less an invitation to critical thinking than a warning about how easily publics can be steered by emotional incentives. In an era defined by propaganda, ideological fervor, and rapidly expanding mass media, the observation reads as both cynical and practical: if people are moved by fear and hope, that’s where power will apply pressure.
The context complicates the moral authority. Duranty is notorious for his Soviet reporting, widely criticized for minimizing or denying atrocities like the Holodomor. That history turns the aphorism into an uncomfortable self-portrait: a man describing the very mechanisms that allowed his audience, and perhaps himself, to accept a preferred story over a brutal reality. The line is incisive, but it also reveals how insight can coexist with evasion.
The subtext is darker. As a journalist, Duranty is sketching the audience he had to persuade, manage, or outmaneuver. It’s less an invitation to critical thinking than a warning about how easily publics can be steered by emotional incentives. In an era defined by propaganda, ideological fervor, and rapidly expanding mass media, the observation reads as both cynical and practical: if people are moved by fear and hope, that’s where power will apply pressure.
The context complicates the moral authority. Duranty is notorious for his Soviet reporting, widely criticized for minimizing or denying atrocities like the Holodomor. That history turns the aphorism into an uncomfortable self-portrait: a man describing the very mechanisms that allowed his audience, and perhaps himself, to accept a preferred story over a brutal reality. The line is incisive, but it also reveals how insight can coexist with evasion.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Walter
Add to List









