"The problem with writing about religion is that you run the risk of offending sincerely religious people, and then they come after you with machetes"
About this Quote
Barry’s genius here is how he smuggles a serious accusation through the side door of a punchline. He starts with a familiar, almost etiquette-column premise: writing about religion is tricky because believers might be offended. Then he detonates the expectation with “machetes,” a ludicrously vivid image that’s funny precisely because it’s so disproportionate to the genteel setup. The laugh is the bait; the snap underneath is about intimidation.
The intent isn’t to argue theology. It’s to spotlight a problem of discourse: religion as a topic where the social penalty for wrong phrasing can feel uniquely high, not just in hurt feelings but in retaliation, censorship, or moral panic. “Sincerely religious people” is doing sly work. It sounds respectful, even charitable, which gives Barry cover; it also needles the idea that sincerity automatically equals virtue. The subtext is that conviction can become a license to police others, and that “offense” isn’t always an emotional response - it can be a weaponized pretext.
Context matters: Barry wrote in an American culture that prizes free speech as a civic religion while treating actual religion as a third rail. His hyperbole riffs on headlines about extremist violence without naming a group, which is both why the line lands and why it’s risky. The joke collapses a wide spectrum of believers into a threat, then dares you to notice the mechanism: fear narrows what gets said. Comedy, in Barry’s hands, isn’t escape; it’s a pressure test for how tolerant a society is of being mocked.
The intent isn’t to argue theology. It’s to spotlight a problem of discourse: religion as a topic where the social penalty for wrong phrasing can feel uniquely high, not just in hurt feelings but in retaliation, censorship, or moral panic. “Sincerely religious people” is doing sly work. It sounds respectful, even charitable, which gives Barry cover; it also needles the idea that sincerity automatically equals virtue. The subtext is that conviction can become a license to police others, and that “offense” isn’t always an emotional response - it can be a weaponized pretext.
Context matters: Barry wrote in an American culture that prizes free speech as a civic religion while treating actual religion as a third rail. His hyperbole riffs on headlines about extremist violence without naming a group, which is both why the line lands and why it’s risky. The joke collapses a wide spectrum of believers into a threat, then dares you to notice the mechanism: fear narrows what gets said. Comedy, in Barry’s hands, isn’t escape; it’s a pressure test for how tolerant a society is of being mocked.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Dave
Add to List
