"The proverb warns that 'You should not bite the hand that feeds you.' But maybe you should, if it prevents you from feeding yourself"
About this Quote
Szasz takes a nursery-level moral - gratitude as obedience - and flips it into a warning about dependency. The original proverb polices behavior: don't challenge the benefactor, don't risk your rations. His revision keeps the animal metaphor but changes the scene from manners to power. The hand that feeds you is no longer benevolent; it's a mechanism that can train you into helplessness. "Maybe you should" is the key move: a controlled provocation that licenses ingratitude when gratitude becomes a leash.
The subtext is classic Szasz: suspicion of institutions that present care as virtue while quietly claiming authority over your choices. As a psychiatrist who spent decades attacking coercive psychiatry, he heard "help" and "treatment" as words that can smuggle in control - particularly when the patient is redefined as incompetent to steer their own life. In that context, biting isn't petulance; it's a refusal to accept a relationship where survival depends on pleasing the provider.
The line also works because it stages a trade-off that liberal societies prefer not to look at directly: security can erode agency. "Feeding yourself" stands in for adult autonomy - economic, psychological, political. Szasz doesn't romanticize rebellion; he frames it as prophylaxis. Better a small act of conflict now than a permanent condition of being managed later. The wit is in the inversion, but the sting is in the accusation: sometimes the safest-looking kindness is the thing that keeps you from becoming capable.
The subtext is classic Szasz: suspicion of institutions that present care as virtue while quietly claiming authority over your choices. As a psychiatrist who spent decades attacking coercive psychiatry, he heard "help" and "treatment" as words that can smuggle in control - particularly when the patient is redefined as incompetent to steer their own life. In that context, biting isn't petulance; it's a refusal to accept a relationship where survival depends on pleasing the provider.
The line also works because it stages a trade-off that liberal societies prefer not to look at directly: security can erode agency. "Feeding yourself" stands in for adult autonomy - economic, psychological, political. Szasz doesn't romanticize rebellion; he frames it as prophylaxis. Better a small act of conflict now than a permanent condition of being managed later. The wit is in the inversion, but the sting is in the accusation: sometimes the safest-looking kindness is the thing that keeps you from becoming capable.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Thomas
Add to List




