"The public can only be really moved by what is genuine"
About this Quote
Lewes is giving a backhanded rebuke to every performer, politician, and moral entrepreneur who thinks the crowd is a keyboard you can program. “Only” is doing the heavy lifting: it turns the line into a rule, almost a dare. You can charm the public, distract it, even stampede it for a while, but to “really” move it - to change what it feels, believes, and carries forward - requires something sturdier than technique. The sentence flatters ordinary people while quietly disciplining elites: the audience is not endlessly gullible; it has a deep sensor for the real.
The subtext is Victorian but familiar: an age of mass print, celebrity lecturers, melodrama, and reform campaigns where sincerity was both prized and performed. Lewes, a philosopher and critic steeped in theatre and psychology (and partnered with George Eliot, whose novels obsess over moral authenticity), is allergic to empty eloquence. “Genuine” here isn’t just honesty as a personal virtue; it’s congruence between inner conviction and outward expression. The public may not parse arguments like philosophers do, but it can smell the mismatch between tone and truth.
The line also contains a warning about counterfeit “genuineness.” If the public can be moved only by the genuine, then the quickest route to power is to manufacture the appearance of it - the rehearsed vulnerability, the curated plainspokenness, the indignation on cue. Lewes’s claim works because it’s both idealistic and suspicious: it insists on authenticity while acknowledging how badly our culture wants to fake it.
The subtext is Victorian but familiar: an age of mass print, celebrity lecturers, melodrama, and reform campaigns where sincerity was both prized and performed. Lewes, a philosopher and critic steeped in theatre and psychology (and partnered with George Eliot, whose novels obsess over moral authenticity), is allergic to empty eloquence. “Genuine” here isn’t just honesty as a personal virtue; it’s congruence between inner conviction and outward expression. The public may not parse arguments like philosophers do, but it can smell the mismatch between tone and truth.
The line also contains a warning about counterfeit “genuineness.” If the public can be moved only by the genuine, then the quickest route to power is to manufacture the appearance of it - the rehearsed vulnerability, the curated plainspokenness, the indignation on cue. Lewes’s claim works because it’s both idealistic and suspicious: it insists on authenticity while acknowledging how badly our culture wants to fake it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by George
Add to List





