"The public gets not one penny from them in return for those airwaves"
About this Quote
McChesney’s line is a small grenade lobbed at a big American myth: that the airwaves are “free” because we can turn on a radio or TV without paying a bill. The bite comes from the inversion. He reminds you that the spectrum is public property, licensed out under the pretense of serving the public interest. So when he says “not one penny,” he’s not doing accounting. He’s accusing an entire system of taking a common resource and privatizing the upside.
The phrasing is deliberately plain, almost prosecutorial. “The public” sits first in the sentence like the injured party in a case caption. “Airwaves” evokes something natural, even innocent, which makes the implied extraction feel dirtier. And “in return” is the moral hinge: this isn’t about whether media companies make content people like; it’s about whether they’ve met the civic obligations that justify their control of a scarce, government-managed asset.
Context matters. McChesney’s career has been a sustained critique of U.S. media deregulation, especially the late-20th-century shift that treated broadcasting less as a public trustee model and more as an advertising-delivery business. The subtext is that we’ve normalized a one-way transaction: corporations monetize attention, consolidate power, and influence politics, while the public gets “content” and is told that’s payment enough. By reducing the complaint to a single penny, he exposes how lopsided the bargain has become, and how quietly we’ve accepted it.
The phrasing is deliberately plain, almost prosecutorial. “The public” sits first in the sentence like the injured party in a case caption. “Airwaves” evokes something natural, even innocent, which makes the implied extraction feel dirtier. And “in return” is the moral hinge: this isn’t about whether media companies make content people like; it’s about whether they’ve met the civic obligations that justify their control of a scarce, government-managed asset.
Context matters. McChesney’s career has been a sustained critique of U.S. media deregulation, especially the late-20th-century shift that treated broadcasting less as a public trustee model and more as an advertising-delivery business. The subtext is that we’ve normalized a one-way transaction: corporations monetize attention, consolidate power, and influence politics, while the public gets “content” and is told that’s payment enough. By reducing the complaint to a single penny, he exposes how lopsided the bargain has become, and how quietly we’ve accepted it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List

