Skip to main content

Daily Inspiration Quote by Calvin Trillin

"The question about those aromatic advertisements that perfume companies are having stitched into magazines these days is this: under the freedoms guaranteed by the First Amendment, is smelling up the place a constitutionally protected form of expression?"

About this Quote

Trillin’s genius here is that he treats a trivial modern annoyance as if it’s a founding-era crisis, and the mismatch does all the work. “Aromatic advertisements” aren’t just marketing; they’re an invasion method, literally stitched into the shared public space of a magazine. By framing the gripe as a First Amendment question, he inflates the consumer’s petty irritation into constitutional drama, then lets the reader notice how easily our language of rights gets recruited to defend whatever the market dreams up next.

The specific intent is less to litigate free speech than to lampoon the way corporations borrow the cultural prestige of “expression” to sanitize intrusion. Perfume ads don’t persuade through argument; they bypass the brain and go straight for the nervous system. That’s why the phrase “smelling up the place” lands: it yanks the ad down from aspirational fantasy to the blunt fact of odor, the kind you can’t unsee or, crucially, un-smell. In print media, you can avert your eyes. With scent, you’re conscripted.

The subtext is about consent and the shrinking boundaries between private experience and commercial messaging. A magazine used to be a controlled encounter: you chose what to read, what to skip. Scent inserts convert reading into exposure. Trillin’s joke also glances at late-20th-century rights talk, where “freedom” becomes a multipurpose shield, and the question isn’t “Should they?” but “Can they get away with it?” The punchline is the category error: calling an assault on your nostrils “speech” reveals how elastic the idea of expression becomes when money is speaking.

Quote Details

TopicFreedom
More Quotes by Calvin Add to List
Is smelling up the place protected expression
Click to enlarge Portrait | Landscape

About the Author

USA Flag

Calvin Trillin (born December 5, 1935) is a Journalist from USA.

8 more quotes available

View Profile

Similar Quotes