"The question I asked Georges has now become a general one - You, who thought you were superfluous, who thought there was no place for you in society, not only are you not superfluous, you are needed and so those who were beggars become givers"
About this Quote
The context matters. Abbe Pierre built his public authority through the Emmaus movement and postwar France’s housing crises, moments when institutional solutions lagged and human need was visible in the streets. His genius was to frame poverty not as a deficit of character but as a deficit of belonging. By naming “beggars become givers,” he doesn’t romanticize hardship; he weaponizes agency. The poor are not redeemed by being helped, they’re redeemed by being entrusted.
Subtext: this is also a rebuke to the comfortable. If those deemed useless are “needed,” then the real superfluity sits elsewhere: in idle wealth, bureaucratic distance, and moral spectatorship. The phrase “general one” signals a move from an intimate conversation (“Georges”) to a social indictment. It’s an argument for solidarity that avoids sentimentalism by offering a practical reversal: give people a task, and you give them a place.
Quote Details
| Topic | Human Rights |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Pierre, Abbe. (2026, January 17). The question I asked Georges has now become a general one - You, who thought you were superfluous, who thought there was no place for you in society, not only are you not superfluous, you are needed and so those who were beggars become givers. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/the-question-i-asked-georges-has-now-become-a-37105/
Chicago Style
Pierre, Abbe. "The question I asked Georges has now become a general one - You, who thought you were superfluous, who thought there was no place for you in society, not only are you not superfluous, you are needed and so those who were beggars become givers." FixQuotes. January 17, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/the-question-i-asked-georges-has-now-become-a-37105/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"The question I asked Georges has now become a general one - You, who thought you were superfluous, who thought there was no place for you in society, not only are you not superfluous, you are needed and so those who were beggars become givers." FixQuotes, 17 Jan. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/the-question-i-asked-georges-has-now-become-a-37105/. Accessed 19 Feb. 2026.









