"The reader really has to step up to the plate and read a short story"
About this Quote
Wolff’s line smuggles an entire aesthetic manifesto into the blunt idiom of baseball: no one gets walked to first in a short story. “Step up to the plate” is a demand for agency, but it’s also a sly rebuke to the consumer fantasy of frictionless reading. The short story, in Wolff’s telling, is not a “small novel” you can skim for plot; it’s a high-pressure at-bat where every pitch matters and the count changes fast.
The intent is craft-practical and slightly combative. Wolff came up in the postwar American short story tradition where compression is virtue and omission is muscle: Chekhov’s restraint filtered through Carver-era minimalism, with moral consequence humming under the surface. A short story doesn’t have space to earn your patience gradually. It asks the reader to do the connective work - to infer histories from a gesture, stakes from a line of dialogue, dread from what’s not said. That’s the subtext: the story is a collaboration, and your laziness will show.
The sports metaphor also carries a democratic jab. Baseball is familiar, almost stubbornly plainspoken, which makes the challenge feel less like academic gatekeeping and more like a fair warning: you will be pitched curves. Wolff’s own stories often pivot on reversals of self-knowledge; the reader who “steps up” is the one willing to be fooled, then to notice they were fooled, then to sit with what that says about them.
The intent is craft-practical and slightly combative. Wolff came up in the postwar American short story tradition where compression is virtue and omission is muscle: Chekhov’s restraint filtered through Carver-era minimalism, with moral consequence humming under the surface. A short story doesn’t have space to earn your patience gradually. It asks the reader to do the connective work - to infer histories from a gesture, stakes from a line of dialogue, dread from what’s not said. That’s the subtext: the story is a collaboration, and your laziness will show.
The sports metaphor also carries a democratic jab. Baseball is familiar, almost stubbornly plainspoken, which makes the challenge feel less like academic gatekeeping and more like a fair warning: you will be pitched curves. Wolff’s own stories often pivot on reversals of self-knowledge; the reader who “steps up” is the one willing to be fooled, then to notice they were fooled, then to sit with what that says about them.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by Tobias
Add to List
