"The real problem is arranging that experience in a way that tells a story, which is just incredible enough to be interesting, but credible enough to be believed"
About this Quote
Helms is talking like a man who spent a career turning chaos into something that can survive contact with an audience. The line sounds like craft talk about memoir or screenwriting, but the subtext is colder: power depends on narrative discipline. “Experience” is raw material; it doesn’t persuade on its own. It has to be arranged, curated, edited. That verb is doing the heavy lifting. Arranging implies selection, omission, and emphasis - the quiet mechanics of making reality legible, and therefore usable.
The tightrope Helms names is the one every persuasive institution walks: if the story is too ordinary, nobody listens; if it’s too wild, nobody trusts it. “Incredible enough… credible enough” is practically a manual for selling an account that can’t be fully verified, the kind of story that circulates precisely because the listener can’t audit it. It’s also an admission that belief is not a moral category here; it’s a design problem. The target isn’t truth, but plausibility.
Context matters. Richard Helms wasn’t a pop celebrity in any meaningful sense; he was a CIA director in the thick of the Cold War, later convicted of misleading Congress. That history gives the quote an edge: it reads less like a writer’s insight and more like the worldview of an intelligence operator who understands that secrecy creates a vacuum, and stories rush in to fill it. In that vacuum, the most effective narrative isn’t the truest one; it’s the one that lands.
The tightrope Helms names is the one every persuasive institution walks: if the story is too ordinary, nobody listens; if it’s too wild, nobody trusts it. “Incredible enough… credible enough” is practically a manual for selling an account that can’t be fully verified, the kind of story that circulates precisely because the listener can’t audit it. It’s also an admission that belief is not a moral category here; it’s a design problem. The target isn’t truth, but plausibility.
Context matters. Richard Helms wasn’t a pop celebrity in any meaningful sense; he was a CIA director in the thick of the Cold War, later convicted of misleading Congress. That history gives the quote an edge: it reads less like a writer’s insight and more like the worldview of an intelligence operator who understands that secrecy creates a vacuum, and stories rush in to fill it. In that vacuum, the most effective narrative isn’t the truest one; it’s the one that lands.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by Richard
Add to List
