"The reality, sitting ten thousand miles away, is that we remain the country that inspires. We remain that shining city on a hill"
About this Quote
Ten thousand miles is doing more work here than the patriotism. Huntsman plants the listener in exile first, then rebuilds the country in the mind: not as a set of policies or messy headlines, but as an idea that can travel. It’s a politician’s classic pivot from geography to mythology, and it’s engineered to flatter both speaker and audience. If America still “inspires” from that far away, it must be less a nation than a brand with global reach.
The subtext is defensive. “We remain” repeats like a mantra because the claim is insecure; you don’t insist on permanence unless you feel it slipping. This line lands in the post-Iraq, post-financial-crisis, increasingly multipolar era, when American credibility abroad felt less like an inheritance and more like a negotiation. Huntsman, a diplomat-politician who literally lived “ten thousand miles away” as ambassador, is trading on authority: I’ve seen the view from the outside, and I’m here to reassure you.
Then there’s the borrowed glow of “shining city on a hill,” the Puritan-to-Reagan totem that turns national power into moral destiny. It’s rhetorically potent because it dodges specifics. “City” suggests order, light, and community; “hill” implies visibility and judgment. The phrase invites pride while quietly demanding performance: if you claim to be the beacon, you’re also admitting the world is watching for hypocrisy.
What makes the quote work is its double audience. At home, it’s balm. Abroad, it’s an argument that American leadership is still legitimate because it’s aspirational. The trick is that aspiration can sound like humility, even when it’s a bid to keep the spotlight.
The subtext is defensive. “We remain” repeats like a mantra because the claim is insecure; you don’t insist on permanence unless you feel it slipping. This line lands in the post-Iraq, post-financial-crisis, increasingly multipolar era, when American credibility abroad felt less like an inheritance and more like a negotiation. Huntsman, a diplomat-politician who literally lived “ten thousand miles away” as ambassador, is trading on authority: I’ve seen the view from the outside, and I’m here to reassure you.
Then there’s the borrowed glow of “shining city on a hill,” the Puritan-to-Reagan totem that turns national power into moral destiny. It’s rhetorically potent because it dodges specifics. “City” suggests order, light, and community; “hill” implies visibility and judgment. The phrase invites pride while quietly demanding performance: if you claim to be the beacon, you’re also admitting the world is watching for hypocrisy.
What makes the quote work is its double audience. At home, it’s balm. Abroad, it’s an argument that American leadership is still legitimate because it’s aspirational. The trick is that aspiration can sound like humility, even when it’s a bid to keep the spotlight.
Quote Details
| Topic | Pride |
|---|
More Quotes by Jon
Add to List
