"The rise of the Dutch Republic must ever be regarded as one of the leading events of modern times"
About this Quote
Motley isn’t just praising the Netherlands; he’s lobbying for a whole way of reading modern history. By declaring the Dutch Republic’s rise “one of the leading events of modern times,” he’s elevating a small, commercially minded, waterlogged corner of Europe into a proving ground for the ideas 19th-century liberals most wanted to claim as destiny: religious toleration (at least relative to its neighbors), representative government, and the moral legitimacy of revolt against empire.
The line works because it sounds like neutral historiography while quietly staging a political argument. “Must ever be regarded” is the tell: it’s not an observation, it’s a directive. Motley is policing the canon of “modern times,” insisting that modernity isn’t primarily born in royal courts or battlefield grandeur but in merchant cities, printing presses, financial instruments, and a citizenry that can bankroll its own survival. The Dutch Revolt becomes less a regional rebellion against Spain than a prototype for the Atlantic world’s later revolutions and for the Anglo-American story of constitutional liberty.
Context sharpens the subtext. Motley wrote as an American in a century of nation-building and self-congratulating progress narratives, when history often doubled as civic instruction. Casting the Dutch as early champions of freedom also flatters Protestant, English-speaking audiences: it frames Spain as the reactionary foil and turns the Republic into an ancestor worth inheriting. The sentence’s grandeur is deliberate; it’s how you make a trading republic feel like an epic turning point rather than an accounting miracle with cannons.
The line works because it sounds like neutral historiography while quietly staging a political argument. “Must ever be regarded” is the tell: it’s not an observation, it’s a directive. Motley is policing the canon of “modern times,” insisting that modernity isn’t primarily born in royal courts or battlefield grandeur but in merchant cities, printing presses, financial instruments, and a citizenry that can bankroll its own survival. The Dutch Revolt becomes less a regional rebellion against Spain than a prototype for the Atlantic world’s later revolutions and for the Anglo-American story of constitutional liberty.
Context sharpens the subtext. Motley wrote as an American in a century of nation-building and self-congratulating progress narratives, when history often doubled as civic instruction. Casting the Dutch as early champions of freedom also flatters Protestant, English-speaking audiences: it frames Spain as the reactionary foil and turns the Republic into an ancestor worth inheriting. The sentence’s grandeur is deliberate; it’s how you make a trading republic feel like an epic turning point rather than an accounting miracle with cannons.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by John
Add to List