"The same things that lead to disparities in health in this country on a day-to-day basis led to disparities in the impact of Hurricane Katrina"
About this Quote
Katrina didn’t invent inequality; it simply made it impossible to look away. David Satcher’s line is a neat piece of moral accounting: if you want to understand why a “natural” disaster killed and displaced people unevenly, stop treating the storm as the whole story and start tallying the daily conditions that pre-selected who could flee, who could recover, and who would be left waiting.
The specific intent is diagnostic, almost clinical. Satcher collapses the false divide between public health and public safety by insisting they’re the same system wearing different uniforms. “Day-to-day basis” is doing quiet, devastating work here. It frames disparity not as an occasional crisis but as a routine operating mode: housing quality, chronic disease, access to transportation, insurance, and political attention. When the levees failed, those background variables became foreground fate.
The subtext pushes back against a familiar American comfort: the idea that catastrophe is random, tragic, and therefore blameless. Satcher’s phrasing doesn’t accuse individuals; it indicts structures. Disparities in “impact” aren’t just about who got wet. They’re about who had cars, cash, prescriptions, evacuation plans, and a government that treated them as urgent.
Context matters. Coming from a physician-statesman steeped in population health, this isn’t rhetorical flourish; it’s a demand that we read Katrina as a public health event with a long prehistory. The storm becomes a stress test that the country failed, not because nature was cruel, but because policy was.
The specific intent is diagnostic, almost clinical. Satcher collapses the false divide between public health and public safety by insisting they’re the same system wearing different uniforms. “Day-to-day basis” is doing quiet, devastating work here. It frames disparity not as an occasional crisis but as a routine operating mode: housing quality, chronic disease, access to transportation, insurance, and political attention. When the levees failed, those background variables became foreground fate.
The subtext pushes back against a familiar American comfort: the idea that catastrophe is random, tragic, and therefore blameless. Satcher’s phrasing doesn’t accuse individuals; it indicts structures. Disparities in “impact” aren’t just about who got wet. They’re about who had cars, cash, prescriptions, evacuation plans, and a government that treated them as urgent.
Context matters. Coming from a physician-statesman steeped in population health, this isn’t rhetorical flourish; it’s a demand that we read Katrina as a public health event with a long prehistory. The storm becomes a stress test that the country failed, not because nature was cruel, but because policy was.
Quote Details
| Topic | Health |
|---|
More Quotes by David
Add to List



