"The Scriptures were written, not to make us astronomers, but to make us saints"
About this Quote
Henry draws a hard boundary between curiosity and conversion, and he does it with a line that quietly demotes an entire category of human pride. “Not to make us astronomers” isn’t an anti-science sneer so much as a surgical strike against the impulse to treat the Bible as a cosmic instruction manual - a text you can mine for data, timelines, and secret codes, then display like trophies. He’s warning that you can read Scripture the way you read the sky: measuring, mapping, mastering. And still miss the point.
The rhetorical punch comes from the pairing. “Astronomers” represents the prestige of explanation: the clean, public thrill of getting the universe to add up. “Saints” represents the messy, private labor of moral change. Henry knows which one people would rather be applauded for. The quote works because it flips the expected hierarchy: the higher calling isn’t knowledge about the heavens but holiness on earth.
The context matters. Henry is writing in the wake of the Scientific Revolution, when astronomy had become the flagship of modern certainty. Newton’s Principia lands in 1687; the culture is newly intoxicated with laws, systems, and proofs. Protestants, especially, were also battling over interpretation, worried that cleverness could replace obedience. Henry’s line pushes back on a faith that becomes a parlor game for the educated.
Subtext: don’t use God as a shortcut to intellectual status. A Bible wielded to win arguments can leave the reader untouched. Henry’s priority is telos: Scripture isn’t primarily for informing the mind, but for reforming the person.
The rhetorical punch comes from the pairing. “Astronomers” represents the prestige of explanation: the clean, public thrill of getting the universe to add up. “Saints” represents the messy, private labor of moral change. Henry knows which one people would rather be applauded for. The quote works because it flips the expected hierarchy: the higher calling isn’t knowledge about the heavens but holiness on earth.
The context matters. Henry is writing in the wake of the Scientific Revolution, when astronomy had become the flagship of modern certainty. Newton’s Principia lands in 1687; the culture is newly intoxicated with laws, systems, and proofs. Protestants, especially, were also battling over interpretation, worried that cleverness could replace obedience. Henry’s line pushes back on a faith that becomes a parlor game for the educated.
Subtext: don’t use God as a shortcut to intellectual status. A Bible wielded to win arguments can leave the reader untouched. Henry’s priority is telos: Scripture isn’t primarily for informing the mind, but for reforming the person.
Quote Details
| Topic | Bible |
|---|
More Quotes by Matthew
Add to List
