"The so-called modern education, with all its defects, however, does others so much more good than it does the Negro, because it has been worked out in conformity to the needs of those who have enslaved and oppressed weaker peoples"
About this Quote
Woodson’s “so-called” is doing surgical work: it punctures the self-congratulating aura around “modern education” before the sentence even gets going. He concedes “with all its defects” not to soften his claim, but to widen it. Even a flawed system can still be net-beneficial to the people it was designed for. The scandal, in his framing, is design. Education isn’t failing Black students by accident; it succeeds at a different job.
The punch of the line is how it reassigns agency. Woodson refuses the common diagnosis that the Negro is “behind” because of individual deficiency or cultural lag. Instead, he describes schooling as a technology of power “worked out in conformity” with the needs of enslavers and empire-builders. That bureaucratic phrasing is the point: domination doesn’t require constant cruelty when it can be routinized into curricula, standards, and prestige. The system’s “neutral” knowledge becomes a quiet form of coercion, teaching the oppressed to admire the oppressor’s worldview and to treat their own history as footnote or absence.
Context matters: writing in the Jim Crow era, Woodson is arguing against an education that trains Black Americans to fit into a racial hierarchy rather than interrogate it. His larger project (most famously in The Mis-Education of the Negro) is not anti-intellectualism; it’s a demand for intellectual self-determination. He’s insisting that what counts as “education” is a political decision disguised as common sense. The sentence lands because it forces a modern reader to ask an uncomfortable question: who is the school actually for?
The punch of the line is how it reassigns agency. Woodson refuses the common diagnosis that the Negro is “behind” because of individual deficiency or cultural lag. Instead, he describes schooling as a technology of power “worked out in conformity” with the needs of enslavers and empire-builders. That bureaucratic phrasing is the point: domination doesn’t require constant cruelty when it can be routinized into curricula, standards, and prestige. The system’s “neutral” knowledge becomes a quiet form of coercion, teaching the oppressed to admire the oppressor’s worldview and to treat their own history as footnote or absence.
Context matters: writing in the Jim Crow era, Woodson is arguing against an education that trains Black Americans to fit into a racial hierarchy rather than interrogate it. His larger project (most famously in The Mis-Education of the Negro) is not anti-intellectualism; it’s a demand for intellectual self-determination. He’s insisting that what counts as “education” is a political decision disguised as common sense. The sentence lands because it forces a modern reader to ask an uncomfortable question: who is the school actually for?
Quote Details
| Topic | Equality |
|---|---|
| Source | Carter G. Woodson, The Mis-Education of the Negro, 1933 (contains the passage beginning "The so-called modern education..."). |
More Quotes by Carter
Add to List
