"The spirit of moderation should also be the spirit of the lawgiver"
About this Quote
Moderation, for Montesquieu, isnt a personality trait; its a constitutional technology. Writing in the age of absolutist monarchs and religious wars still warm in Europes memory, he treats political power the way an engineer treats pressure: not with moral pleading, but with design. A lawgiver who lacks moderation doesnt just make harsh laws; he builds a system that invites abuse, because law is the language power uses to justify itself.
The line carries a quiet rebuke to the heroic fantasy of politics, the idea that a great leader can fix society by force of will. Montesquieus subtext is that zeal is the enemy of durability. When legislators are animated by certainty - religious, ideological, even reformist - they tend to confuse their private conviction with public reason. Moderation becomes the antidote to that category error: laws should be calibrated to human limitations, conflicting interests, and the stubborn fact that people will interpret rules for advantage.
Its also a strategic move. Montesquieu argues elsewhere that liberty survives when power checks power; moderation is the temperament that makes checks possible without paralysis. A moderate lawgiver doesnt abolish conflict; he anticipates it, distributes authority, and writes rules that can be lived with by rivals. The rhetoric is deceptively calm, but the warning is sharp: the immoderate legislator is a revolutionary in robes, and the robe is what makes him dangerous.
The line carries a quiet rebuke to the heroic fantasy of politics, the idea that a great leader can fix society by force of will. Montesquieus subtext is that zeal is the enemy of durability. When legislators are animated by certainty - religious, ideological, even reformist - they tend to confuse their private conviction with public reason. Moderation becomes the antidote to that category error: laws should be calibrated to human limitations, conflicting interests, and the stubborn fact that people will interpret rules for advantage.
Its also a strategic move. Montesquieu argues elsewhere that liberty survives when power checks power; moderation is the temperament that makes checks possible without paralysis. A moderate lawgiver doesnt abolish conflict; he anticipates it, distributes authority, and writes rules that can be lived with by rivals. The rhetoric is deceptively calm, but the warning is sharp: the immoderate legislator is a revolutionary in robes, and the robe is what makes him dangerous.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Charles
Add to List





