"The statists want to control the economy"
About this Quote
Norquist’s line is less a description than a sorting mechanism: a way to divide the room into people who “get it” and people who are presumed to be dangerous. “The statists” isn’t a neutral label. It’s a loaded category that collapses Democrats, technocrats, regulators, and even moderate Republicans into a single ominous bloc. The vagueness is the point. By refusing to name policies (antitrust? labor rules? environmental standards?), he turns a messy democratic argument into an existential threat: them versus freedom.
“Want to control” also does rhetorical work. It frames economic governance not as coordination, risk management, or redistribution, but as domination - an impulse, almost a pathology. In that framing, motives are illegitimate by definition; evidence becomes secondary to intent. You don’t debate a controller. You resist one.
The context is Norquist’s long career as an anti-tax enforcer and movement tactician, most famously through Americans for Tax Reform and the “Taxpayer Protection Pledge.” His political project depends on making government action in the market feel inherently suspect, so that the default posture is austerity and deregulation. Labeling opponents “statists” helps keep the coalition disciplined: if raising revenue is “control,” then compromise looks like surrender.
The subtext is a moral rebranding of the economy itself. Markets become synonymous with liberty; policy becomes coercion. It’s a compact sentence built for repetition on talk radio and fundraising emails, not for precision. Its power lies in how quickly it turns a policy dispute into a character judgment.
“Want to control” also does rhetorical work. It frames economic governance not as coordination, risk management, or redistribution, but as domination - an impulse, almost a pathology. In that framing, motives are illegitimate by definition; evidence becomes secondary to intent. You don’t debate a controller. You resist one.
The context is Norquist’s long career as an anti-tax enforcer and movement tactician, most famously through Americans for Tax Reform and the “Taxpayer Protection Pledge.” His political project depends on making government action in the market feel inherently suspect, so that the default posture is austerity and deregulation. Labeling opponents “statists” helps keep the coalition disciplined: if raising revenue is “control,” then compromise looks like surrender.
The subtext is a moral rebranding of the economy itself. Markets become synonymous with liberty; policy becomes coercion. It’s a compact sentence built for repetition on talk radio and fundraising emails, not for precision. Its power lies in how quickly it turns a policy dispute into a character judgment.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Grover
Add to List
