Skip to main content

Daily Inspiration Quote by Anatole Broyard

"The tension between "yes" and "no," between "I can" and "I cannot," makes us feel that, in so many instances, human life is an interminable debate with one's self"

About this Quote

Broyard pins a whole theory of consciousness to four blunt syllables: yes, no, can, cannot. It’s a critic’s move - reduce the sprawling mess of “human life” to a small, repeatable argument and let the repetition do the work. The line is less a lament than a diagnosis: what exhausts us isn’t just external pressure but the ceaseless internal cross-examination, the way every desire arrives with its own rebuttal already attached.

The phrasing matters. “Tension” suggests not a tidy choice but a stretched muscle, a held breath. “Interminable debate” makes the self sound like a committee that never adjourns, always drafting amendments to its own impulses. Broyard’s subtext is that modern life trains us to experience agency as litigation: we prosecute and defend ourselves, collecting evidence (“I can”) and counter-evidence (“I cannot”) until action feels almost secondary.

As a cultural critic who wrote with the intimacy of a memoirist, Broyard is also quietly advertising a method. Critics live in the hinge between affirmation and refusal: liking and dismissing, granting and withholding legitimacy. He projects that professional posture inward, implying that taste, ambition, illness, love - all of it - becomes a critical exercise. The “interminable” part isn’t merely psychological; it’s historical. In an era that sells self-realization while multiplying constraints (money, status, identity, mortality), the self becomes the arena where competing scripts argue for control. Broyard makes that argument feel true because he refuses uplift. No pep talk, just the honest static of being human.

Quote Details

TopicWisdom
SourceHelp us find the source
More Quotes by Anatole Add to List
The Inner Debate of Yes and No
Click to enlarge Portrait | Landscape

About the Author

USA Flag

Anatole Broyard (July 19, 1920 - October 11, 1990) was a Critic from USA.

12 more quotes available

View Profile

Similar Quotes

Earl Butz, Public Servant