"The transmission systems are still regulated"
About this Quote
“The transmission systems are still regulated” is the kind of sentence that wears a hard hat and carries a briefcase: technocratic, reassuring, and carefully incomplete. Coming from Kenneth Lay, it reads less like an observation than a pressure valve. In the late-1990s and early-2000s push to deregulate energy markets, the public fear was simple: if you let companies compete on price, they’ll also compete on safety and reliability, and the grid will become collateral damage. Lay’s line answers that fear with a bureaucratic lullaby. Don’t worry, the wires are still watched.
The specific intent is to draw a bright line between “markets” and “infrastructure,” suggesting that deregulation is a controlled experiment, not a bonfire. It’s a rhetorical move that converts a complex, interdependent system into two separate boxes: generation and trading can be liberated, while transmission remains a neutral, regulated backbone. That separation is exactly where the subtext lives. It implies that what Enron and its peers were doing - financial innovation, aggressive trading, creative contract structures - operated safely above the physical grid, like capitalism in the cloud.
Context makes the sentence sting. California’s electricity crisis and Enron’s collapse exposed how thin that comfort was: you can’t fully firewall the “regulated” from the “market” when incentives and bottlenecks collide. Regulation of transmission may keep the poles standing, but it doesn’t prevent strategic congestion, price manipulation, or the political offloading of blame. Lay’s wording is doing reputational work, not engineering work - a reminder that in deregulation debates, the most powerful tool isn’t a turbine, it’s a plausible-sounding boundary.
The specific intent is to draw a bright line between “markets” and “infrastructure,” suggesting that deregulation is a controlled experiment, not a bonfire. It’s a rhetorical move that converts a complex, interdependent system into two separate boxes: generation and trading can be liberated, while transmission remains a neutral, regulated backbone. That separation is exactly where the subtext lives. It implies that what Enron and its peers were doing - financial innovation, aggressive trading, creative contract structures - operated safely above the physical grid, like capitalism in the cloud.
Context makes the sentence sting. California’s electricity crisis and Enron’s collapse exposed how thin that comfort was: you can’t fully firewall the “regulated” from the “market” when incentives and bottlenecks collide. Regulation of transmission may keep the poles standing, but it doesn’t prevent strategic congestion, price manipulation, or the political offloading of blame. Lay’s wording is doing reputational work, not engineering work - a reminder that in deregulation debates, the most powerful tool isn’t a turbine, it’s a plausible-sounding boundary.
Quote Details
| Topic | Technology |
|---|
More Quotes by Kenneth
Add to List



