"The troops were occasionally occupied in pursuing scattered bands going north or south, and on three occasions the large camp of Sitting Bull ventured south of the Canadian border, and important expeditions were sent against them"
About this Quote
Military prose that sounds like paperwork is often where power hides best. Nelson A. Miles gives us a sentence engineered to make violent state pursuit feel like routine management: troops were merely "occupied", Indigenous fighters reduced to "scattered bands", and Sitting Bull’s people reimagined not as a community seeking refuge but as a "large camp" that "ventured" across an abstract line on a map. The diction is administrative, almost bored. That’s the point. It drains moral heat from what is, in effect, cross-border pressure on a displaced nation.
The context is the post-Little Bighorn era, when the U.S. Army was determined to break Lakota resistance and force surrender, even as some groups moved into Canada to escape U.S. retaliation. Miles, a senior officer and later commanding general of the Army, helped professionalize the frontier wars into a story of logistics and "expeditions" rather than conquest. Notice how the border becomes the moral centerpiece: the camp "ventured south of the Canadian border" as if transgressing a neutral rule, while the U.S. response - "important expeditions" - reads like a justified corrective, not an escalation.
The subtext is sovereignty, and who gets to claim it. Sitting Bull’s mobility is framed as a provocation; the Army’s mobility is framed as responsibility. Even "important" does quiet ideological work, signaling legitimacy and gravity without mentioning objectives like starvation tactics, coercion, or the political demand for submission. Miles isn’t only reporting operations; he’s laundering them into the language of order.
The context is the post-Little Bighorn era, when the U.S. Army was determined to break Lakota resistance and force surrender, even as some groups moved into Canada to escape U.S. retaliation. Miles, a senior officer and later commanding general of the Army, helped professionalize the frontier wars into a story of logistics and "expeditions" rather than conquest. Notice how the border becomes the moral centerpiece: the camp "ventured south of the Canadian border" as if transgressing a neutral rule, while the U.S. response - "important expeditions" - reads like a justified corrective, not an escalation.
The subtext is sovereignty, and who gets to claim it. Sitting Bull’s mobility is framed as a provocation; the Army’s mobility is framed as responsibility. Even "important" does quiet ideological work, signaling legitimacy and gravity without mentioning objectives like starvation tactics, coercion, or the political demand for submission. Miles isn’t only reporting operations; he’s laundering them into the language of order.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|
More Quotes by Nelson
Add to List
