"The truth cannot be asserted without denouncing the falsehood"
About this Quote
Victorian liberalism liked to imagine it could float above the muck: reasoned, temperate, self-correcting. Leslie Stephen punctures that fantasy with a sentence that treats “truth” not as a serene artifact but as an action with consequences. The line is structured like a trapdoor. “Asserted” sounds calm, almost procedural; “denouncing” is moral, public, and inevitably combative. Stephen’s point is that clarity is never neutral. The moment you speak plainly, you’re not just adding information to the world; you’re taking sides in an argument someone else is invested in keeping blurry.
The subtext is about courage and cost. To “assert” truth is to invite retaliation from the systems, institutions, or habits that benefit from the lie. Stephen was writing in a culture that prized civility and suspicion of “controversy” as bad taste. He’s insisting that the desire to be above the fray is itself a political position, one that often props up the status quo. There’s also a subtle rebuke to the complacent reformer: if you think you can tell the truth without naming what’s untrue, you’re probably protecting someone.
Context matters. As a leading intellectual in an era of Darwinian upheaval, religious doubt, and fierce debates over science, morality, and empire, Stephen knew that “truth” arrived with a social bill attached. His sentence is a defense of polemic as a necessary hygiene: denunciation not as theatrics, but as the price of intellectual honesty in a world that runs on comforting fictions.
The subtext is about courage and cost. To “assert” truth is to invite retaliation from the systems, institutions, or habits that benefit from the lie. Stephen was writing in a culture that prized civility and suspicion of “controversy” as bad taste. He’s insisting that the desire to be above the fray is itself a political position, one that often props up the status quo. There’s also a subtle rebuke to the complacent reformer: if you think you can tell the truth without naming what’s untrue, you’re probably protecting someone.
Context matters. As a leading intellectual in an era of Darwinian upheaval, religious doubt, and fierce debates over science, morality, and empire, Stephen knew that “truth” arrived with a social bill attached. His sentence is a defense of polemic as a necessary hygiene: denunciation not as theatrics, but as the price of intellectual honesty in a world that runs on comforting fictions.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|
More Quotes by Leslie
Add to List
