"The truth is, man is hereunto led by reason which is his nature"
About this Quote
Reason is doing double duty here: it is both a description of what humans are and a political demand for how they ought to live. Algernon Sidney isn’t offering a gentle bit of Renaissance humanism; he’s building a justification for resistance. In 17th-century England, when kings and their theorists leaned hard on divine right and inherited authority, Sidney counters with a rival sovereignty: the human mind. If reason is our nature, then being "led" by it is not optional, not a private preference, but the baseline standard by which power should be judged.
The phrasing matters. "The truth is" signals a courtroom posture, a deliberate rejection of mysticism or tradition as sufficient proof. "Hereunto led" implies direction without coercion: reason guides rather than compels, a subtle argument against rule by fear, force, or mere custom. Sidney’s subtext is that legitimate government must be intelligible to the governed. If political authority can’t be defended in rational terms, it has no moral claim on obedience.
Sidney wrote in the long shadow of civil war, regicide, restoration, and the Exclusion Crisis, and he would ultimately be executed for alleged treason. That biography sharpens the line: reason becomes an ethical weapon, a way to sanctify dissent without invoking religion. He’s staking out a proto-liberal anthropology: humans are not born to submit, but to deliberate, consent, and revise the terms of their own rule.
The phrasing matters. "The truth is" signals a courtroom posture, a deliberate rejection of mysticism or tradition as sufficient proof. "Hereunto led" implies direction without coercion: reason guides rather than compels, a subtle argument against rule by fear, force, or mere custom. Sidney’s subtext is that legitimate government must be intelligible to the governed. If political authority can’t be defended in rational terms, it has no moral claim on obedience.
Sidney wrote in the long shadow of civil war, regicide, restoration, and the Exclusion Crisis, and he would ultimately be executed for alleged treason. That biography sharpens the line: reason becomes an ethical weapon, a way to sanctify dissent without invoking religion. He’s staking out a proto-liberal anthropology: humans are not born to submit, but to deliberate, consent, and revise the terms of their own rule.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|
More Quotes by Algernon
Add to List







