"The tunes, rhythms, and messages are drawn mainly from secular culture"
About this Quote
A clergyman doesn’t say “secular culture” by accident; he says it like a boundary line. Richard Morris is naming a leak in the walls of the church: music - the most bodily, contagious part of worship - absorbing its materials from outside the sanctuary. “Tunes, rhythms, and messages” is a triplet that escalates from the technical to the theological. Tunes can be borrowed innocently, rhythms can sneak in through fashion, but “messages” implies an ideological smuggling operation. The syntax does quiet work, too: “drawn mainly” suggests not an isolated lapse but a dominant pipeline, a structural dependency.
Placed in the 19th-century Protestant world, the complaint lands amid mass urbanization, popular entertainments, and the expanding marketplace of song. Hymnody is becoming democratized, emotionally direct, and easy to memorize - the same traits that make secular music commercially powerful. Morris isn’t only worried about impurity; he’s anxious about competition. If people can get their catharsis, their community, their catchy refrains somewhere else, the church loses one of its strongest technologies of belonging.
The line also betrays a begrudging respect. Borrowing “mainly” from secular culture admits that secular culture is where the craft is. The church is reacting, not leading. Under the moral language sits an institutional fear: once worship sounds like the street, it may also start to think like the street, and authority has to negotiate rather than command.
Placed in the 19th-century Protestant world, the complaint lands amid mass urbanization, popular entertainments, and the expanding marketplace of song. Hymnody is becoming democratized, emotionally direct, and easy to memorize - the same traits that make secular music commercially powerful. Morris isn’t only worried about impurity; he’s anxious about competition. If people can get their catharsis, their community, their catchy refrains somewhere else, the church loses one of its strongest technologies of belonging.
The line also betrays a begrudging respect. Borrowing “mainly” from secular culture admits that secular culture is where the craft is. The church is reacting, not leading. Under the moral language sits an institutional fear: once worship sounds like the street, it may also start to think like the street, and authority has to negotiate rather than command.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Richard
Add to List







