"The unions may continue to decline, but if they do, it'll be their fault"
About this Quote
Delors delivers a reprimand disguised as a forecast. The line pretends to be descriptive - unions may continue to decline - then snaps into judgment: if they do, it'll be their fault. That pivot does the real work. It drags the conversation away from convenient villains (globalization, hostile governments, deregulatory waves, the long shadow of deindustrialization) and plants responsibility inside the labor movement itself. Not innocence lost, but agency squandered.
The subtext is distinctly technocratic: institutions survive when they modernize. Delors, an economist and EU statesman, came of age in the postwar settlement when unions were not just interest groups but pillars of social bargaining. By the late 20th century, that settlement was fraying under capital mobility, service-sector employment, and political projects that treated collective bargaining as an impediment to competitiveness. Delors is signaling that nostalgia is not a strategy. If unions cling to narrow occupational identities, protect insiders at the expense of precarious workers, or treat reform as betrayal, they will make themselves irrelevant.
There's also a quiet political bargain embedded here. Delors was associated with "social Europe": market integration tempered by social protections. His warning doubles as an invitation - adapt, broaden, professionalize, and you can still be a legitimate partner at the table. Fail, and the table will be set without you, and no one will be persuaded it was inevitable.
The sting is that "fault" frames decline as deserved. It's a managerial language of performance applied to solidarity, which is precisely Delors's provocation: unions must learn to win in a world that no longer guarantees them a seat.
The subtext is distinctly technocratic: institutions survive when they modernize. Delors, an economist and EU statesman, came of age in the postwar settlement when unions were not just interest groups but pillars of social bargaining. By the late 20th century, that settlement was fraying under capital mobility, service-sector employment, and political projects that treated collective bargaining as an impediment to competitiveness. Delors is signaling that nostalgia is not a strategy. If unions cling to narrow occupational identities, protect insiders at the expense of precarious workers, or treat reform as betrayal, they will make themselves irrelevant.
There's also a quiet political bargain embedded here. Delors was associated with "social Europe": market integration tempered by social protections. His warning doubles as an invitation - adapt, broaden, professionalize, and you can still be a legitimate partner at the table. Fail, and the table will be set without you, and no one will be persuaded it was inevitable.
The sting is that "fault" frames decline as deserved. It's a managerial language of performance applied to solidarity, which is precisely Delors's provocation: unions must learn to win in a world that no longer guarantees them a seat.
Quote Details
| Topic | Work |
|---|
More Quotes by Jacques
Add to List