"The United States Constitution has proved itself the most marvelously elastic compilation of rules of government ever written"
About this Quote
Calling the Constitution "marvelously elastic" is Roosevelt’s way of turning a potential weakness into a civic superpower. Elasticity suggests stretch, not rupture: a framework that can absorb modern pressures without snapping into authoritarianism or paralysis. Coming from a president who expanded the federal state on an unprecedented scale, the compliment is also a defense brief. FDR isn’t praising parchment for its own sake; he’s arguing that constitutional legitimacy can travel with political change.
The intent is strategic. In the New Deal era, critics accused Roosevelt of bulldozing tradition, centralizing power, and treating emergencies as blank checks. By framing the Constitution as an adaptable "compilation of rules", he lowers the temperature of doctrinal worship. It’s not a sacred relic; it’s a working instrument. That word choice matters: "compilation" sounds practical, almost bureaucratic, undercutting the romantic idea that any deviation from 18th-century expectations is betrayal.
The subtext is a rebuke to constitutional fundamentalism and a preemptive answer to the Supreme Court battles of the 1930s, when the Court struck down key New Deal programs and Roosevelt flirted with court reform. Elasticity becomes a democratic argument: if a modern industrial society can’t govern itself through the existing charter, the problem isn’t reformers; it’s a too-rigid reading of the text.
Context sharpens the stakes. The world Roosevelt led was defined by economic collapse, mass unemployment, and the rise of fascism abroad. Against that backdrop, "elastic" signals resilience: a constitutional order capable of emergency action while staying recognizably constitutional. It’s constitutional faith, yes, but not the museum kind. It’s faith in adaptation as the antidote to breakdown.
The intent is strategic. In the New Deal era, critics accused Roosevelt of bulldozing tradition, centralizing power, and treating emergencies as blank checks. By framing the Constitution as an adaptable "compilation of rules", he lowers the temperature of doctrinal worship. It’s not a sacred relic; it’s a working instrument. That word choice matters: "compilation" sounds practical, almost bureaucratic, undercutting the romantic idea that any deviation from 18th-century expectations is betrayal.
The subtext is a rebuke to constitutional fundamentalism and a preemptive answer to the Supreme Court battles of the 1930s, when the Court struck down key New Deal programs and Roosevelt flirted with court reform. Elasticity becomes a democratic argument: if a modern industrial society can’t govern itself through the existing charter, the problem isn’t reformers; it’s a too-rigid reading of the text.
Context sharpens the stakes. The world Roosevelt led was defined by economic collapse, mass unemployment, and the rise of fascism abroad. Against that backdrop, "elastic" signals resilience: a constitutional order capable of emergency action while staying recognizably constitutional. It’s constitutional faith, yes, but not the museum kind. It’s faith in adaptation as the antidote to breakdown.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|
More Quotes by Franklin
Add to List






