"The United States is not, and never will be, at war with Islam"
About this Quote
A line like this is less reassurance than preemptive damage control, delivered with the calm authority of a commander in chief trying to narrow a dangerously elastic definition of “the enemy.” Obama’s phrasing does two things at once: it draws a hard boundary around legitimate military action (against groups and states) and refuses the sweeping civilizational frame that post-9/11 rhetoric often flirted with. The force is in the absolutes. “Is not” addresses the present fever; “never will be” attempts to bind the future, staking a moral and strategic claim that the U.S. cannot afford a permanent religious war without sabotaging its own security.
The subtext is aimed at multiple audiences who rarely hear the same sentence the same way. To Muslim Americans and Muslim-majority allies, it’s a pledge of belonging and a bid for cooperation: you are not suspect by default, and your partnership matters. To domestic hawks, it’s a rebuke without calling anyone out: if you insist on treating Islam itself as the adversary, you’re doing terrorists’ recruiting for them. To extremist propaganda, it’s a refusal to validate their central narrative that the West is waging war on a faith.
Context matters: Obama inherited two wars and a national security state built on fear and broad categories. He also governed amid rising anti-Muslim politics at home. The sentence tries to keep counterterrorism from metastasizing into cultural conflict, because once a conflict becomes theological, victory stops being definable and legitimacy starts bleeding out.
The subtext is aimed at multiple audiences who rarely hear the same sentence the same way. To Muslim Americans and Muslim-majority allies, it’s a pledge of belonging and a bid for cooperation: you are not suspect by default, and your partnership matters. To domestic hawks, it’s a rebuke without calling anyone out: if you insist on treating Islam itself as the adversary, you’re doing terrorists’ recruiting for them. To extremist propaganda, it’s a refusal to validate their central narrative that the West is waging war on a faith.
Context matters: Obama inherited two wars and a national security state built on fear and broad categories. He also governed amid rising anti-Muslim politics at home. The sentence tries to keep counterterrorism from metastasizing into cultural conflict, because once a conflict becomes theological, victory stops being definable and legitimacy starts bleeding out.
Quote Details
| Topic | Peace |
|---|---|
| Source | Remarks by the President at Cairo University, 'A New Beginning' (Cairo, June 4, 2009). Line: "Let me be clear: The United States is not -- and never will be -- at war with Islam." |
More Quotes by Barack
Add to List