"The use of solar energy has not been opened up because the oil industry does not own the sun"
About this Quote
Nader lands the punch with a line that sounds like a joke until you remember it’s also an indictment. “The oil industry does not own the sun” is a deliberately simple image: abundant, public, borderless energy contrasted with a market built on scarcity, control, and gatekeeping. The wit is strategic. By choosing the sun - something literally impossible to privatize - he exposes how energy policy often behaves as if the only viable resources are the ones already bundled into powerful ownership structures.
The specific intent is to reframe the clean-energy debate away from engineering and toward political economy. Nader isn’t arguing that solar didn’t develop because it was technically unready; he’s suggesting it was politically unready. Industries don’t just compete on product; they compete on the rules of the game: subsidies, research priorities, permitting, utility regulation, infrastructure lock-in, and the soft power that shapes “common sense” about what’s realistic. Solar threatens that model because it decentralizes production and weakens the leverage that comes from controlling extraction, refining, and distribution chokepoints.
Subtext: energy transitions aren’t neutral, and “innovation” doesn’t naturally rise to the top. It gets escorted - or blocked. Coming from a consumer advocate who spent decades treating corporate power as a design flaw in American democracy, the line functions as a compressed theory of capture. It’s also a provocation: if no one can own the sun, the next best strategy is to own everything around it - panels, patents, grids, financing - and to stall the moment when sunlight becomes a serious competitor.
The specific intent is to reframe the clean-energy debate away from engineering and toward political economy. Nader isn’t arguing that solar didn’t develop because it was technically unready; he’s suggesting it was politically unready. Industries don’t just compete on product; they compete on the rules of the game: subsidies, research priorities, permitting, utility regulation, infrastructure lock-in, and the soft power that shapes “common sense” about what’s realistic. Solar threatens that model because it decentralizes production and weakens the leverage that comes from controlling extraction, refining, and distribution chokepoints.
Subtext: energy transitions aren’t neutral, and “innovation” doesn’t naturally rise to the top. It gets escorted - or blocked. Coming from a consumer advocate who spent decades treating corporate power as a design flaw in American democracy, the line functions as a compressed theory of capture. It’s also a provocation: if no one can own the sun, the next best strategy is to own everything around it - panels, patents, grids, financing - and to stall the moment when sunlight becomes a serious competitor.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Ralph
Add to List


