"The vehemence with which certain critics have chosen not simply to criticize what I've written, but to challenge my writing this story at all, speaks of what the book is about: fear of disapproval"
About this Quote
Maynard doesn’t just defend a book here; she flips the power dynamic that critics usually enjoy. The key move is her distinction between “criticize what I’ve written” and “challenge my writing this story at all.” One is normal literary pushback. The other is a gatekeeping reflex: the impulse to police who gets to speak, what subjects are permissible, and which lived experiences are “allowed” into public narrative.
Her phrase “the vehemence with which certain critics have chosen” subtly implies intention and appetite. This isn’t careful disagreement; it’s heat, urgency, maybe even moral panic. That matters because it casts the critics as participants in the very psychological economy her book targets. By saying their reaction “speaks of what the book is about,” Maynard turns reception into evidence. The backlash becomes a live demonstration of the theme, not a refutation of it.
The subtext is personal and political at once: women writers, in particular, know the difference between being reviewed and being told they’re indecent for writing in the first place. “Fear of disapproval” isn’t framed as an internal weakness; it’s a social control mechanism, enforced through public shaming and the threat of reputational damage. Maynard’s line suggests that the harshest critics aren’t merely responding to prose or plot. They’re responding to the audacity of self-disclosure, to the idea that a writer might claim authority over her own story.
Contextually, it reads like an author speaking from inside a culture that treats certain narratives as transgressive until they’re sanitized, commodified, or told by someone “approved.” Her intent is clear: name the policing, then refuse it.
Her phrase “the vehemence with which certain critics have chosen” subtly implies intention and appetite. This isn’t careful disagreement; it’s heat, urgency, maybe even moral panic. That matters because it casts the critics as participants in the very psychological economy her book targets. By saying their reaction “speaks of what the book is about,” Maynard turns reception into evidence. The backlash becomes a live demonstration of the theme, not a refutation of it.
The subtext is personal and political at once: women writers, in particular, know the difference between being reviewed and being told they’re indecent for writing in the first place. “Fear of disapproval” isn’t framed as an internal weakness; it’s a social control mechanism, enforced through public shaming and the threat of reputational damage. Maynard’s line suggests that the harshest critics aren’t merely responding to prose or plot. They’re responding to the audacity of self-disclosure, to the idea that a writer might claim authority over her own story.
Contextually, it reads like an author speaking from inside a culture that treats certain narratives as transgressive until they’re sanitized, commodified, or told by someone “approved.” Her intent is clear: name the policing, then refuse it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Fear |
|---|
More Quotes by Joyce
Add to List
