"The very idea of carrying my memory into eternity devastated me, and I took refuge in atheism"
About this Quote
Immortality is supposed to be the consolation prize; Caldwell flips it into a horror story. The line hinges on a deliciously unsettling reversal: eternity isn’t comforting because it preserves love or justice, it’s crushing because it preserves you. Not the polished self you present at dinner, but the full archive - the embarrassing motives, the private cruelties, the versions of you you’ve tried to outgrow. “Carrying my memory into eternity” sounds almost physical, like hauling a suitcase you can’t put down. The devastation isn’t fear of death; it’s fear of unending self-awareness.
The refuge in atheism is the sharp psychological turn. Caldwell frames unbelief less as a conclusion reached by reason than as a shelter sought for survival. If there’s no afterlife, then there’s also no cosmic witness, no divine hard drive backing up every thought. Oblivion becomes mercy. In a culture where atheism is often caricatured as cold or defiant, she casts it as a kind of anesthesia - an escape from metaphysical claustrophobia.
Context matters: Caldwell wrote in the long 20th century, when mass death, war, and disillusionment made traditional promises feel thinner, even when the hunger for meaning stayed intense. The subtext is a novelist’s: identity is not a stable, heroic thing. It’s a messy narrative under constant revision. Eternity would freeze it, trap the protagonist in an uneditable final draft. Atheism, here, is not emptiness; it’s the only way to let the story end.
The refuge in atheism is the sharp psychological turn. Caldwell frames unbelief less as a conclusion reached by reason than as a shelter sought for survival. If there’s no afterlife, then there’s also no cosmic witness, no divine hard drive backing up every thought. Oblivion becomes mercy. In a culture where atheism is often caricatured as cold or defiant, she casts it as a kind of anesthesia - an escape from metaphysical claustrophobia.
Context matters: Caldwell wrote in the long 20th century, when mass death, war, and disillusionment made traditional promises feel thinner, even when the hunger for meaning stayed intense. The subtext is a novelist’s: identity is not a stable, heroic thing. It’s a messy narrative under constant revision. Eternity would freeze it, trap the protagonist in an uneditable final draft. Atheism, here, is not emptiness; it’s the only way to let the story end.
Quote Details
| Topic | Mortality |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Taylor
Add to List
