"The Viennese wash everything. Where else in the world does the government hire public servants to wash public telephone booths and the glass over traffic lights? Every time I see someone doing these things, I smile like a child"
About this Quote
Vienna, in Carroll's telling, is a city that treats cleanliness like a civic art form, almost a public religion. The image is deliberately small-bore: not grand boulevards or imperial facades, but the glass over traffic lights and telephone booths, the kinds of surfaces most cities let cloud over into ambient neglect. By zooming in on this mundane maintenance, he praises a government not for ideology or efficiency in the abstract, but for a tactile, visible care that citizens can literally see through.
The subtext is less about hygiene than about dignity. When the state pays someone to polish the overlooked corners of shared life, it signals that public space belongs to everyone and is worth tending. It's a quiet rebuke to the urban default elsewhere: infrastructure that decays until it becomes background noise, then gets explained away as "realism". Carroll's question, "Where else in the world...?" carries a soft incredulity that doubles as cultural critique, implying that many governments can fund spectacle but balk at maintenance.
The childlike smile is the real tell. This isn't adult admiration for order; it's wonder at being cared for by systems that usually feel indifferent. Coming from a novelist known for the uncanny slipping into the everyday, the moment reads like a benign version of magic: the city performs an act of invisible labor and, suddenly, the world looks newly legible. Clean glass becomes a metaphor for civic transparency, not as policy, but as experience.
The subtext is less about hygiene than about dignity. When the state pays someone to polish the overlooked corners of shared life, it signals that public space belongs to everyone and is worth tending. It's a quiet rebuke to the urban default elsewhere: infrastructure that decays until it becomes background noise, then gets explained away as "realism". Carroll's question, "Where else in the world...?" carries a soft incredulity that doubles as cultural critique, implying that many governments can fund spectacle but balk at maintenance.
The childlike smile is the real tell. This isn't adult admiration for order; it's wonder at being cared for by systems that usually feel indifferent. Coming from a novelist known for the uncanny slipping into the everyday, the moment reads like a benign version of magic: the city performs an act of invisible labor and, suddenly, the world looks newly legible. Clean glass becomes a metaphor for civic transparency, not as policy, but as experience.
Quote Details
| Topic | Smile |
|---|
More Quotes by Jonathan
Add to List
