"The whole Indian thing, I always say it's really the American holocaust. It's something we need to look at"
About this Quote
Calling it “the American holocaust” is a blunt rhetorical shortcut: Skeet Ulrich reaches for the most culturally legible symbol of genocide to jolt an audience that’s been trained to file Native history under “frontier” myth or Thanksgiving pageantry. As an actor, not a historian, he’s speaking in the language of impact, not footnotes. The intent is less to litigate terminology than to force moral recognition: what happened to Indigenous peoples wasn’t an unfortunate side effect of nation-building, it was mass death, dispossession, and state-backed erasure.
The subtext is accusation-by-contrast. Americans are comfortable treating the Holocaust as a civic lesson about evil and responsibility; Ulrich is pointing out how rarely the United States applies that same ethical clarity to its own origin story. “The whole Indian thing” is doing quiet work here too. The casual phrasing mirrors the very minimization he’s critiquing, as if he’s mimicking the way mainstream culture reduces centuries of violence into a vague, sanitized “thing.” Then he pivots: “we need to look at it.” Not “remember,” not “acknowledge,” but “look,” as in stare down the evidence we keep skirting.
Context matters because the analogy is both powerful and risky. It can open a door to public reckoning - land theft, forced removals, boarding schools, cultural destruction - while also inviting pushback for flattening distinct histories into a single emblem. Ulrich’s line works because it treats amnesia as the real enemy, using a loaded comparison to make denial socially harder to maintain.
The subtext is accusation-by-contrast. Americans are comfortable treating the Holocaust as a civic lesson about evil and responsibility; Ulrich is pointing out how rarely the United States applies that same ethical clarity to its own origin story. “The whole Indian thing” is doing quiet work here too. The casual phrasing mirrors the very minimization he’s critiquing, as if he’s mimicking the way mainstream culture reduces centuries of violence into a vague, sanitized “thing.” Then he pivots: “we need to look at it.” Not “remember,” not “acknowledge,” but “look,” as in stare down the evidence we keep skirting.
Context matters because the analogy is both powerful and risky. It can open a door to public reckoning - land theft, forced removals, boarding schools, cultural destruction - while also inviting pushback for flattening distinct histories into a single emblem. Ulrich’s line works because it treats amnesia as the real enemy, using a loaded comparison to make denial socially harder to maintain.
Quote Details
| Topic | Human Rights |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Skeet
Add to List
