"The will is never free - it is always attached to an object, a purpose. It is simply the engine in the car - it can't steer"
About this Quote
Cary’s line is a bracing demotion of the heroic “free will” story modern culture loves to sell itself. The will, he argues, isn’t a sovereign driver making clean, autonomous choices; it’s torque. It converts fuel into motion, but it doesn’t pick the destination. The steering comes from something messier: desire, belief, fear, habit, ideology, love. That’s the subtext doing the real work: most of what we call “willpower” is just commitment to a prior attachment we didn’t fully author.
The metaphor matters because it drags philosophy out of the clouds and into the garage. An engine can be powerful and still be useless without direction; it can also propel you straight into a wall if the steering is broken. Cary is quietly shifting the moral center of gravity. If the will isn’t “free,” then praising or blaming people for sheer grit becomes suspect. The more relevant question becomes: attached to what? A purpose can dignify the will or corrupt it. The sentence reads like a warning against confusing intensity with judgment.
Contextually, a mid-20th-century novelist is primed to distrust tidy agency. Cary wrote in a world shaped by war, propaganda, class systems, and psychological realism - forces that make “choice” feel compromised and character feel determined by pressures inside and outside the self. In that light, the quote isn’t fatalism so much as a call for better steering: examine the objects of devotion before revving the engine.
The metaphor matters because it drags philosophy out of the clouds and into the garage. An engine can be powerful and still be useless without direction; it can also propel you straight into a wall if the steering is broken. Cary is quietly shifting the moral center of gravity. If the will isn’t “free,” then praising or blaming people for sheer grit becomes suspect. The more relevant question becomes: attached to what? A purpose can dignify the will or corrupt it. The sentence reads like a warning against confusing intensity with judgment.
Contextually, a mid-20th-century novelist is primed to distrust tidy agency. Cary wrote in a world shaped by war, propaganda, class systems, and psychological realism - forces that make “choice” feel compromised and character feel determined by pressures inside and outside the self. In that light, the quote isn’t fatalism so much as a call for better steering: examine the objects of devotion before revving the engine.
Quote Details
| Topic | Free Will & Fate |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Joyce
Add to List







